Paul L. Caron
Dean





Thursday, March 23, 2023

Law School Deans See Through The U.S. News Rankings Bluster

William M. Treanor (Dean, Georgetown), U.S. News and World Report Has a New, Aggressive Defense of Its Rankings. Law School Deans Like Me See It for What It Is.:

US News (2023)Since 1987, U.S. News & World Report has been ranking law schools. While the law school rankings have been criticized for decades, this year more than 40 law schools have announced they will not participate, and earlier this month, representatives of more than 100 law schools attended a conference to discuss a solution, hosted by Harvard and Yale law schools (the first schools to pull out), and featuring Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona.

In anticipation of the Harvard-Yale conference, U.S. News, which had been relatively quiet in the face of past criticism, responded ferociously, running a full-page ad in the Boston Globe and a Wall Street Journal op-ed defending the ranking system. In the op-ed, U.S. News’ executive chairman and CEO Eric J. Gertler suggested that law schools were withdrawing from U.S. News because, in anticipation of the Supreme Court’s possible invalidation of affirmative action in admissions, they want to be able to ignore grades and standardized test scores in admitting students, without suffering a drop in their U.S. News ranking.

Continue reading

March 23, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, March 22, 2023

WSJ: The Unraveling Of The U.S. News Rankings

Wall Street Journal, The Unraveling of the U.S. News College Rankings:

U.S. News Generic (2020)Yale Law School Dean Heather Gerken floated the idea past a small circle of colleagues. She had a sleepless night and queasy morning. And then, on Nov. 16, she started the revolt.

“The U.S. News rankings are profoundly flawed,” Ms. Gerken said in a letter that day. And with that, Yale Law pulled out.

Within three months, more than 40 law schools—about 20% of the programs that U.S. News ranks—said they would also end their cooperation and no longer share data with the publication, including 12 of the top 14. A wave of medical schools, led by No. 1 Harvard Medical School, followed. At the undergraduate level, the Rhode Island School of Design (No. 3 among regional universities in the North) and Colorado College (No. 27 in the latest measure of national liberal-arts colleges) withdrew last month.

The rebellion, which has thrown into tumult the most famous source of college rankings for generations of would-be students, was decades in the making.

Continue reading

March 22, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, March 21, 2023

2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings

U.S. News & World Report has announced that the new 2024 law school rankings will be publicly released on Tuesday, April 18 (law schools will receive an embargoed copy on Tuesday, April 11). Here is my coverage of the current 2023 law school rankings:

Continue reading

March 21, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, March 16, 2023

Preview Of The 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings: Ultimate Bar Passage

US News (2023)Following up on my previous posts:

The current 2023 methodology year does not include 2018 ultimate 2-year bar passage results. On several occasions, U.S. News has said it would likely add ultimate 2-year bar passage data to its law school rankings, but has not said whether they will include 2019 ultimate 2-year bar passage results in the forthcoming spring 2023 rankings. 

Below are two 2019 ultimate 2-year bar passage rankings. The first is a simple ranking using the pass rate. The second uses Z-scores to better approximate the U.S. News methodology.

 

Law School

Pass Rate Pass Rate (Including Diploma Privilege)
1 Belmont 100.00% 100.00%
1 Marquette 100.00% 100.00%
3 UC-Berkeley 99.69% 99.69%
4 Duke 99.54% 99.54%
5 Chicago 99.49% 99.49%
6 George Mason 99.36% 99.36%
7 Virginia 99.30% 99.30%
8 Baylor 99.29% 99.29%
9 Harvard 99.29% 99.29%
10 Alabama 99.21% 99.21%
11 Yale 99.04% 99.04%
12 Stanford 98.88% 98.88%
13 Minnesota 98.69% 98.69%
13 Northwestern 98.69% 98.69%
15 Michigan 98.34% 98.34%
16 Campbell 98.13% 98.13%
17 NYU 98.11% 98.11%
18 UCLA 98.08% 98.09%
19 Liberty 98.04% 98.04%
20 Penn 97.97% 97.97%
21 Cornell 97.93% 97.93%
22 Ohio Northern 97.87% 97.87%
23 UC-Irvine 97.86% 97.86%
24 Georgia State 97.85% 97.85%
25 Florida 97.83% 97.83%
26 Boston Univ. 97.61% 97.61%
27 Notre Dame 97.37% 97.37%
28 Washington Univ. 97.30% 97.30%
29 Texas 97.29% 97.29%
30 Boston College 97.20% 97.20%
30 Washington & Lee 97.20% 97.20%
32 Florida Int'l 97.16% 97.16%
33 Oklahoma 97.09% 97.09%
34 Vanderbilt 97.06% 97.06%
35 Illinois 96.72% 96.72%
36 Fordham 96.71% 96.71%
37 Texas A&M 96.69% 96.69%
38 Georgia 96.67% 96.69%
39 Georgetown 96.43% 96.43%
40 New Mexico 96.30% 96.30%
41 Utah 96.20% 96.20%
42 Cardozo 96.04% 96.04%
43 Colorado 95.95% 96.05%
44 Florida State 95.88% 95.88%
45 William & Mary 95.81% 95.81%
46 Kansas 95.74% 95.74%
47 Montana 95.65% 95.65%
48 Samford 95.59% 95.59%
49 Columbia 95.58% 95.58%
50 George Washington 95.46% 95.46%

Continue reading

March 16, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, March 15, 2023

Preview Of The 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings: First-Time Bar Passage

US News (2023)Following up on my previous posts:

The current 2023 methodology for the 2020 calendar year is:

Bar passage rate (0.03, previously 0.0225): U.S. News revamped its treatment of bar passage rates to incorporate all graduates who took the bar for the first time. Computations were further modified to de-emphasize the impact of geography on law schools' relative performance.

Specifically, the bar passage rate indicator scored schools on their 2020 first-time test takers' weighted bar passage rates among all jurisdictions (states), then added or subtracted the percentage point difference between those rates and the weighted state average among ABA accredited schools' first-time test takers in the corresponding jurisdictions in 2020. This meant schools that performed best on this ranking factor graduated students whose bar passage rates were both higher than most schools overall, and higher compared with what was typical among graduates who took the bar in corresponding jurisdictions.

For example, if a law school graduated 100 students who first took the bar exam — and 88 took the Florida exam, 10 the Georgia exam and two the South Carolina exam — the school's weighted average rate would use pass rate results that were weighted 88% Florida, 10% Georgia and 2% South Carolina. This computation would then be compared with an index of these jurisdictions' average pass rates — also weighted 88-10-2. (For privacy, school profiles on usnews.com only display bar passage data for jurisdictions with at least 10 test-takers.) Both weighted averages included any graduates who passed the bar with diploma privilege. Diploma privilege is a method for J.D. graduates to be admitted to a state bar and allowed to practice law in that state without taking that state's actual bar examination. Diploma privilege is generally based on attending and graduating from a law school in that state with the diploma privilege.

In previous editions, U.S. News divided each school's first-time bar passage rate in its single jurisdiction with the most test-takers by the average for that lone jurisdiction. This approach effectively excluded many law schools' graduates who took the bar. Dividing by the state average also meant the location of a law school impacted its quotient as much as its graduates' bar passage rate itself. The new arithmetic accounts for average passage rates across all applicable jurisdictions as proxy for each exam's difficulty and reflects that passing the bar is a critical outcome measure in itself.

Below are two first time bar passage rankings. The first is a ranking by the school pass rate for the 2021 calendar year plus the total difference between the school pass rate and the average state pass rate as reported by the ABA. The second uses Z-scores to better approximate the U.S. News methodology.

 

School

School Pass Rate Average State Pass Rate Total Difference School Pass Rate Plus Total Difference Pass Rate Including Diploma Privilege
1 UC-San Francisco* 81.72% 77.05% 81.72% 163.44% 81.72%
2 Missouri-Kansas City* 74.78% 81.76% 74.78% 149.56% 74.78%
3 Montana 100.00% 79.94% 20.06% 120.06% 80.60%
4 Harvard 99.44% 82.04% 17.40% 116.84% 99.44%
5 Chicago 97.75% 79.05% 18.70% 116.45% 90.99%
6 Yale 98.14% 80.69% 17.45% 115.59% 98.14%
7 Michigan 97.18% 79.79% 17.39% 114.57% 97.18%
8 Stanford 97.08% 79.73% 17.35% 114.43% 97.66%
9 Duke 97.21% 80.67% 16.54% 113.75% 97.21%
10 NYU 98.70% 84.24% 14.46% 113.16% 98.70%
11 Kansas 95.92% 78.83% 17.09% 113.01% 95.92%
12 USC 95.00% 77.59% 17.41% 112.41% 95.80%
13 Vanderbilt 95.15% 78.02% 17.13% 112.28% 95.15%
14 Minnesota 95.67% 79.40% 16.27% 111.94% 95.67%
15 UC-Berkeley 94.95% 78.14% 16.81% 111.76% 95.25%
16 Penn 96.46% 81.50% 14.96% 111.42% 96.46%
17 Texas 94.61% 77.95% 16.66% 111.27% 83.88%
18 Northwestern 95.05% 79.00% 16.05% 111.10% 95.05%
19 BYU 96.15% 82.50% 13.65% 109.80% 96.15%
20 Virginia 94.82% 79.90% 14.92% 109.74% 94.82%
21 Georgia 93.75% 77.79% 15.96% 109.71% 93.75%
22 UCLA 93.84% 78.01% 15.83% 109.67% 93.84%
23 William & Mary 93.82% 78.66% 15.16% 108.98% 93.82%
24 Columbia 96.52% 84.22% 12.30% 108.82% 96.52%
25 Texas A&M 92.98% 77.57% 15.41% 108.39% 92.98%
26 Ohio State 93.71% 79.18% 14.53% 108.24% 93.71%
27 Boston College 94.06% 80.65% 13.41% 107.47% 94.06%
28 Seton Hall 89.60% 71.89% 17.71% 107.31% 89.60%
29 Wake Forest* 94.27% 78.63% 12.64% 106.91% 94.27%
30 Boston Univ. 93.53% 80.29% 13.24% 106.77% 93.53%
31 George Washington 93.46% 80.50% 12.96% 106.42% 93.46%
32 Georgetown 93.23% 80.62% 12.61% 105.84% 93.23%
33 Notre Dame 91.67% 77.82% 13.85% 105.52% 91.67%
34 Oklahoma 91.72% 78.13% 13.59% 105.31% 91.72%
35 Belmont 88.54% 71.87% 16.67% 105.21% 88.54%
36 Tennessee 88.50% 72.57% 15.93% 104.43% 88.50%
37 Emory 91.79% 79.37% 12.42% 104.21% 92.16%
38 Washington Univ. 91.63% 79.26% 12.37% 104.00% 91.63%
39 Florida Int'l 86.72% 69.91% 16.81% 103.53% 86.71%
40 George Mason 90.62% 78.54% 12.08% 102.70% 90.63%
41 Wisconsin 90.00% 77.46% 12.54% 102.54% 99.61%
42 Univ. of Washington 92.21% 82.05% 10.16% 102.37% 90.97%
43 Fordham 93.74% 85.33% 8.41% 102.15% 93.73%
44 Penn State-Univ. Park 89.74% 77.68% 12.06% 101.80% 89.74%
45 Villanova 88.24% 74.74% 13.50% 101.74% 88.24%
46 Indiana (Maurer) 89.61% 77.73% 11.88% 101.49% 89.61%
47 Cornell 92.23% 83.03% 9.20% 101.43% 92.23%
48 Texas Tech 88.96% 77.39% 11.57% 100.53% 88.97%
49 Liberty 88.33% 76.60% 11.73% 100.06% 93.81%
50 UC-Irvine 88.72% 77.39% 11.33% 100.05% 88.73%

Continue reading

March 15, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, March 14, 2023

March Madness Law School Bracket: Duke, Northwestern, Texas, Virginia in Final Four

Here is the March Madness Law School Bracket, with outcomes determined by the 2023 U.S. News Law School Rankings (using academic peer reputation as the tiebreaker). The Final Four are Virginia (8), Duke (11), Northwestern (13), and Texas (17), with Virginia beating Northwestern in the championship game.

NCAA 2023 Bracket

Continue reading

March 14, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Preview Of The 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings: Employment

US News (2023)Following up on my previous posts:

The current 2023 methodology for the Class of 2020 is:

Employment rates for 2020 graduates 10 months after graduation (0.14) and at graduation (0.04): For both ranking factors, schools received maximum credit when their J.D. graduates — in alignment with ABA reporting rules — obtained long-term jobs that were full time, not funded by the law school, and where a J.D. degree was an advantage or bar passage was required. In contrast, jobs that were some combination of short term, part time, funded by the law school and/or did not require bar passage received less credit by varying amounts, determined by the combination. For a more detailed explanation, see Notes on Employment Rates, below [at the bottom of this post].

U.S. News has announced that it will not use employment rates at graduation in the forthcoming 2024 rankings for the Class of 2021 because that data is not collected by the ABA. U.S. News plans to give greater weight to student outcomes, so employment rates ten months after graduation presumably will be weighted more than 14%. 

Below are two previews of the 2024 employment rankings. As noted below, U.S. News does not reveal the weights it gives to the 45 different job types, employment statuses, and durations. The first is a simple ranking for the Class of 2021, showing both the former 2023 methodology (including full-time, long-term bar passage required or JD-advantaged jobs, but excluding school-funded jobs and pursuit of a graduate law degree) and the new 2024 methodology (including school-funded jobs and pursuit of a graduate law degree). The second uses Z-scores to better approximate the 2024 U.S. News methodology.

  2023 Methodology 2024 Methodology
School BPR & JD Adv Rank BPR & JD Adv Funded BPR & JD Adv Graduate Studies BPR & JD Adv, Funded, Graduate Rank
Penn 93.0% 24 93.0% 5.8% 0.4% 99.2% 1
Duke 96.8% 2 96.8% 1.6% 0.8% 99.2% 2
Chicago 95.3% 7 95.3% 2.8% 0.9% 99.1% 3
NYU 93.3% 22 93.3% 4.5% 0.6% 98.5% 4
Wake Forest 96.5% 3 96.5% 0.0% 1.7% 98.3% 5
Northwestern 94.1% 15 94.1% 2.9% 0.7% 97.8% 6
Columbia 96.3% 4 96.3% 1.1% 0.2% 97.6% 7
Virginia 93.4% 21 93.4% 3.8% 0.3% 97.5% 8
UC-Berkeley 90.2% 40 90.2% 4.9% 2.1% 97.2% 9
Georgia 97.0% 1 97.0% 0.0% 0.0% 97.0% 10
USC 95.3% 6 95.3% 1.0% 0.5% 96.9% 11
Yale 79.8% 136 79.8% 13.8% 3.2% 96.8% 12
Texas A&M 94.7% 10 94.7% 0.0% 1.8% 96.4% 13
North Carolina 94.7% 9 94.7% 0.0% 1.4% 96.2% 14
Kansas 94.9% 8 94.9% 0.0% 1.0% 95.9% 15
Cornell 94.3% 14 94.3% 1.6% 0.0% 95.9% 16
Stanford 87.0% 76 87.0% 6.0% 2.7% 95.7% 17
UCLA 91.5% 31 91.5% 3.5% 0.6% 95.6% 18
Michigan 93.1% 23 93.1% 1.7% 0.8% 95.6% 19
SMU 92.7% 25 92.7% 0.0% 2.7% 95.5% 20
Texas Tech 95.4% 5 95.4% 0.0% 0.0% 95.4% 21
Florida 90.7% 35 90.7% 0.0% 4.5% 95.2% 22
Arizona State 94.6% 11 94.6% 0.0% 0.4% 95.0% 23
Ohio State 94.4% 13 94.4% 0.6% 0.0% 94.9% 24
Villanova 93.7% 18 93.7% 0.0% 1.1% 94.9% 25
Kentucky 94.0% 17 94.0% 0.0% 0.8% 94.7% 26
Washington Univ. 94.6% 12 94.6% 0.0% 0.0% 94.6% 27
Fordham 94.1% 16 94.1% 0.2% 0.2% 94.6% 28
Wayne State 93.7% 19 93.7% 0.0% 0.8% 94.4% 29
Utah 92.0% 28 92.0% 0.0% 2.3% 94.3% 30
Harvard 88.0% 64 88.0% 4.7% 1.5% 94.3% 31
Oklahoma 93.6% 20 93.6% 0.0% 0.6% 94.2% 32
Vanderbilt 92.7% 26 92.7% 1.0% 0.0% 93.8% 33
Stetson 89.7% 49 89.7% 0.0% 3.8% 93.5% 34
Illinois 90.2% 41 90.2% 0.8% 2.5% 93.4% 35
Minnesota 92.0% 29 92.0% 0.4% 0.9% 93.4% 36
BYU 85.7% 87 85.7% 5.7% 1.9% 93.3% 37
Washington & Lee 89.8% 46 89.8% 0.8% 2.5% 93.2% 38
Georgetown 89.7% 48 89.7% 3.0% 0.4% 93.2% 39
Texas 92.0% 30 92.0% 1.1% 0.0% 93.1% 40
Montana 90.1% 42 90.1% 0.0% 2.8% 93.0% 41
Missouri-Columbia 89.3% 53 89.3% 3.6% 0.0% 92.9% 42
Iowa 92.7% 27 92.7% 0.0% 0.0% 92.7% 43
George Mason 90.7% 36 90.7% 0.6% 1.2% 92.5% 44
Emory 88.9% 56 88.9% 0.4% 3.2% 92.5% 45
St. Thomas (MN) 88.0% 65 88.0% 4.2% 0.0% 92.3% 46
Florida State 87.6% 69 87.6% 0.9% 3.7% 92.2% 47
Boston College 90.8% 34 90.8% 1.3% 0.0% 92.1% 48
South Carolina 90.5% 38 90.5% 0.0% 1.5% 92.0% 49
Pepperdine 90.0% 43 90.0% 1.3% 0.7% 92.0% 50

Continue reading

March 14, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, March 13, 2023

Seto: 2022 First-Time Bar Pass Performance Of California Law Schools, Controlling For 25th Percentile LSATs

TaxProf Blog op-ed:  First-Time Bar Pass Performance of California Law Schools, Controlling For 25th Percentile LSATs, by Theodore Seto (Loyola-L.A.; Google Scholar):

SetoIn a recent TaxProf blog post, Paul Caron ranked all law schools by their 2022 first-time bar passage rates, based on ABA data. Based on that same 2022 data, I then explored the extent to which California law schools over- or under-performed in first-time bar passage after controlling for the median LSATs of their students. After posting my analysis, Paul asked me to replicate that analysis using law schools’ 25th percentile LSATs — in effect, to measure the extent to which California law schools add value to their students most at risk, the bottom quarter of their classes by LSAT.

Because U.S. News uses median LSATs in ranking law schools, schools have the flexibility to take other criteria into account in admitting the bottom half of their classes (by LSAT) without directly affecting their U.S. News ranking (e.g., admitting diverse or first-generation students). To the extent LSATs are predictive of bar passage, however, doing so may negatively affect bar passage rates. Schools can manage this problem in at least two ways: (1) by keeping their 25th percentile LSATs as high as possible, or (2) admitting lower-LSAT students (typically diverse or first-generation students) and devoting resources to maximizing the likelihood that they too will pass the bar. This follow-up analysis therefore looks at the extent to which California law schools are successful in preparing the bottom of their classes for the bar — that is, the value they add to their students most at risk.

Here are the relevant raw data from 2022. The first column is 25th percentile LSATs, the second is distance of the school’s bar passage rate above or below the state average. Schools are listed in the order of 25th percentile, high to low:

Continue reading

March 13, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Friday, March 10, 2023

More Commentary On The U.S. News Law School Rankings Op-Ed

Mike Spivey (Spivey Consulting), Some Commentary on the U.S. News Op-Ed:

US News (2023)U.S. News & World Report is not sitting idle while its rankings come under fire. The CEO published an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal offering his views on the rankings boycott. ...

We have been paid money over the years to help law schools understand their U.S. News rankings. It's against our interests as a firm, from a revenue standpoint, for schools to boycott the rankings, and for applicants to stop paying attention to them. But we're telling you that is the best outcome for everyone.

U.S. News has no expertise in law or legal education. They have no expertise in education in general. Imagine if a bunch of lawyers got together and decided to rank the best immunology programs. That's the absurdity of what U.S. News does. At least when Above the Law publishes its rankings they come from actual lawyers and law school graduates.

Continue reading

March 10, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, March 7, 2023

Seto: 2022 First-Time Bar Pass Performance Of California Law Schools, Controlling For Median LSATs

TaxProf Blog op-ed:  First-Time Bar Pass Performance of California Law Schools, Controlling For Median LSATs, by Theodore Seto (Loyola-L.A.; Google Scholar):

SetoIn a recent TaxProf Blog post, Paul Caron ranked all law schools by their 2022 first-time bar passage rates, based on ABA data.

Based on that same 2022 data, I here examine the extent to which California law schools over- or under-performed in first-time bar passage after controlling for the median LSATs of their students. After all, we would expect Stanford students to do well on the bar regardless of the preparation they receive at Stanford. And we would expect students at Southwestern to do worse than Stanford students on the bar, again regardless of the quality of the education they receive at Southwestern. This is because we believe LSATs to be predictive of something—not sure of what—but of something.

What we really should be interested in is not bar pass rates – which are largely a function of the innate academic abilities of schools’ incoming students – but rather the extent to which their students over- or under-perform on the bar exam after controlling for incoming LSATs. In other words, we should be looking at schools’ value added.

Here are the relevant raw data from 2022. The first column is median LSATs, the second is distance of the school’s bar passage rate above or below the state average. Schools are listed in the order of median LSATs, high to low:

Continue reading

March 7, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, March 6, 2023

Muller: Boycotting Law Schools Are Still Admitting 'Splitters' To Maximize Their U.S. News Ranking

Following up on my previous post, Law School Admissions, U.S. News Rankings, And 'Splitters':  Derek Muller (Iowa; Google Scholar), Law Schools Say They're "Boycotting" the USNWR Rankings, But Their Admissions Practices Suggest Otherwise:

Earlier, I pointed out that law schools “boycotting” the USNWR law school rankings really meant that they would not be completing the survey forms circulated to them. ... I also noted that some schools appeared to still be “participating” in other elements of the rankings. Some, for instance, circulated promotional material to prospective USNWR voting faculty about the achievements of their schools and their faculty.

But I wanted to focus on another mismatch between what law schools are saying and what they are doing. And that’s in admissions.

Yale and Harvard, in their opening salvo, lamented the over-emphasize on the median LSAT and UGPA of incoming students. So, the thought might have gone, we are going to consider admissions based on our own criteria, not dictated by USNWR. As I chronicled a decade ago, USNWR significantly distorts the incentives for law school admissions by driving schools to admit students with either an above-target-median LSAT or an above-target-median UGPA. Higher-caliber students who fall just below the cusp are not admitted, as measured by the “index score,” which is most predictive of law school performance. Lower-caliber students who excel on one of these two measures are admitted.

So would boycotting schools simply ignore the consequences of the USNWR formula and instead admit classes less focused on medians? It appears not. With almost pinpoint precision, you can see that law schools continue to target a particular median LSAT and UGPA in their admissions statistics. Self-reported LSD.law, which in various iterations has been a go-to source of self-reported law school admissions information for twenty years, reflects that these law schools, so far, continue to push medians. ...

Continue reading

March 6, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Amar: What Law Schools Rankings Can Learn From College Sports Rankings

Vikram David Amar (Dean, Illinois), Some Thoughts on the Recent Controversies Concerning Law (and Med) School Rankings: Part I in a Series:

US News (2023)[T]here is no doubt that certain specific aspects of U.S. News’ methodology have been the focus of fire by law and medical school critics. One recurring source of criticism has been that these rankings give a false sense of precision because they rank hundreds of schools ordinally. ... 

Another very loud source of criticism of U.S. News these days—that it attaches weight to the standardized test scores of enrolled students (as an indicator of the academic strength of the student body)—has, I must admit, puzzled me a bit. I fully understand that standardized test scores have a disparate impact along racial lines and for that reason they must be used in admissions with a great deal of care. But all the medical schools and law schools who are boycotting themselves attach a fair amount of significance to standardized test scores as part of their admissions processes (at least for now). Medical schools are under no regulatory requirement to do so, yet they have consistently made MCAT scores a relevant factor. And even as the ABA is considering a proposal (that was recently remanded from the ABA’s House of Delegates to the Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar) to remove the requirement that law schools use standardized tests in admissions, a group of 60 or so law deans, including many of the most progressive and diversity-focused law deans in the country, sent a letter to the ABA last fall opposing the elimination of such a requirement (at least without more study of the matter.) As the letter pointed out, “standardized tests—including the LSAT—can be useful as one of several criteria by which to assess whether applicants are capable of succeeding in law school and to enhance the diversity of our incoming classes. . . . Used properly, as one factor in a holistic admissions process, this index score can help identify students who are capable of performing at a satisfactory level.” Moreover, the letter said, if standardized test scores were not used (and if some schools stop using them, others will be pressured into following suit), then other factors, such as college GPAs, may assume even greater weight in admissions decisions, and such other factors might have an equal or greater disparate impact along racial lines. In this regard, it should be remembered that standardized test scores came into wide use a few generations ago in significant part because other admissions criteria—college attended, letters of recommendation, extracurricular activities, etc.—seemed to many to provide unfair advantages to people who come from well-educated, well-heeled and well-connected families. Standardized test scores were added to the mix in part to level the playing field.

Vikram David Amar (Dean, Illinois), More on Ranking Law Schools, and What Can be Learned from Ranking of Sports Teams: Part Two in a Series:

I suggest at least four ways in which rankings of academic institutions can borrow from innovations in college sports rankings. ...

Continue reading

March 6, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Saturday, March 4, 2023

NY Times: Defending Its Rankings, U.S. News Takes Aim At Top Law Schools

New York Times, Defending Its Rankings, U.S. News Takes Aim at Top Law Schools:

US News (2023)U.S. News & World Report said little last fall as Yale, Harvard and other elite law schools announced that they would no longer submit data to the publication’s rankings, charging that the influential list was an engine of inequality.

But in the last few days, U.S. News has fired back. In a public-relations campaign, the publication has accused the schools of trying to avoid accountability on admissions and outcomes for students, and it connected the boycott to a looming Supreme Court decision that could end affirmative action.

“Some law deans are already exploring ways to sidestep any restrictive ruling by reducing their emphasis on test scores and grades — criteria used in our rankings,” Eric J. Gertler, the executive chairman and chief executive of U.S. News, wrote in an opinion essay on Tuesday in The Wall Street Journal.

The conflict is a sign that U.S. News will not shy away from vigorously defending the rankings, which are criticized by many universities but are popular with families — making them potentially another flash point in the country’s divisive debate over education issues.

Continue reading

March 4, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Friday, March 3, 2023

Law School Rankings By Ultimate Bar Passage Rate (2020)

Following up on my previous posts:

Here is the ranking of schools in the  Ultimate Graduation Year 2020 Bar Pass Data from the ABA's spreadsheet released last Friday:

Rank School Pass Rate Pass Rate (Incl.Diploma Privilege)
1 BYU 100.00% 100.00%
1 Chicago 100.00% 100.00%
1 Stanford 100.00% 100.00%
1 Utah 100.00% 100.00%
5 Duke 99.52% 99.53%
6 Minnesota 99.48% 99.48%
7 Louisiana State 99.37% 99.64%
8 UC-Berkeley 99.36% 99.38%
9 Virginia 99.35% 99.36%
10 Baylor 99.23% 99.24%
11 Alabama 99.21% 99.21%
12 Michigan 99.20% 99.20%
13 Texas A&M 99.19% 99.19%
14 NYU 99.14% 99.15%
15 Texas 99.03% 99.04%
16 Harvard 99.01% 99.01%
17 UCLA 99.00% 99.01%
18 Yale 98.96% 98.96%
19 Georgia 98.85% 98.86%
20 Boston Univ. 98.64% 98.65%
21 Regent 98.53% 98.53%
22 USC 98.34% 98.35%
23 Penn 98.34% 98.37%
24 Washington Univ. 98.19% 98.21%
25 William & Mary 97.71% 97.73%
26 Florida Int'l 97.67% 97.67%
27 Colorado 97.65% 97.66%
28 Cornell 97.41% 97.42%
29 Missouri-Columbia 97.37% 97.44%
30 Fordham 97.33% 97.33%
31 Samford 97.20% 97.20%
32 Northwestern 97.11% 97.11%
33 Wake Forest 97.10% 97.10%
34 Boston College 97.07% 97.10%
35 Dayton 97.01% 97.06%
35 New Hampshire 97.01% 97.01%
37 Ohio State 97.00% 97.01%
38 Montana 96.92% 97.06%
39 George Mason 96.88% 96.97%
40 North Carolina 96.86% 96.89%
41 Northeastern 96.83% 96.88%
42 St. Louis 96.79% 96.82%
43 Vanderbilt 96.63% 96.63%
44 Texas Tech 96.61% 96.61%
45 New Mexico 96.46% 96.46%
46 Liberty 96.30% 96.36%
47 Columbia 96.22% 96.22%
48 Loyola-L.A. 96.19% 96.19%
49 George Washington 95.96% 96.06%
50 St. John's 95.95% 95.95%

Continue reading

March 3, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, March 2, 2023

Law School Rankings By 2022 First-Time Bar Passage Rate

Following up on Monday's post, 2022 Bar Pass Rate Fell 2 Percentage Points Due To Fewer 1L Academic Dismissals After Spring 2020 Covid Semester:  here is the ranking of schools in the  Calendar Year 2022 First-Time Takers Bar Pass Data from the ABA's spreadsheet released last Friday:

Rank School School Pass Rate Average State Pass Rate Total Difference
1 Puerto Rico 68.29% 46.84% 21.45%
2 Marquette 100.00% 79.16% 20.84%
3 North Carolina 93.75% 73.27% 20.48%
4 Harvard 98.46% 78.78% 19.68%
5 UCLA 92.47% 73.23% 19.24%
6 UC-Berkeley 93.35% 74.41% 18.94%
7 New Hampshire 86.90% 68.32% 18.58%
8 Stanford 94.41% 75.86% 18.55%
9 Virginia 95.65% 77.93% 17.72%
10 Yale 95.77% 78.40% 17.37%
11 Chicago 94.26% 77.00% 17.26%
12 Michigan 95.05% 77.81% 17.24%
13 Duke 94.39% 77.21% 17.18%
14 William & Mary 93.90% 76.87% 17.03%
15 Northwestern 92.89% 76.19% 16.70%
16 Baylor 91.97% 75.29% 16.68%
17 Regent 92.59% 76.28% 16.31%
18 Notre Dame 92.72% 76.53% 16.19%
19 Tennessee 88.39% 72.36% 16.03%
20 Florida Int'l 80.25% 64.23% 16.02%
21 Wake Forest 89.84% 73.96% 15.88%
22 Belmont 87.07% 71.54% 15.53%
23 Illinois 90.48% 74.99% 15.49%
24 Oklahoma 85.19% 69.78% 15.41%
25 Washington Univ. 92.34% 76.98% 15.36%
26 USC 89.00% 73.65% 15.35%
27 Penn 93.77% 78.59% 15.18%
28 Vanderbilt* 93.18% 76.94% 15.11%
29 Penn State-Dickinson 88.31% 73.45% 14.86%
30 Texas* 86.12% 76.00% 14.64%
31 Seton Hall 85.71% 71.43% 14.28%
32 Minnesota 93.48% 79.21% 14.27%
33 Florida State* 77.94% 64.62% 14.09%
34 Washington & Lee* 90.27% 77.18% 13.89%
34 NYU 94.90% 81.01% 13.89%
34 Richmond 91.07% 77.18% 13.89%
37 Texas A&M 89.41% 75.53% 13.88%
38 Arizona State 84.50% 71.66% 12.84%
39 Georgetown 91.63% 78.97% 12.66%
40 Boston Univ. 91.82% 79.23% 12.59%
41 Columbia 93.72% 81.24% 12.48%
42 Connecticut 85.38% 73.02% 12.36%
43 Penn State-Univ. Park 86.29% 74.18% 12.11%
44 Missouri-Columbia 90.59% 78.66% 11.93%
45 SMU* 85.33% 75.44% 11.91%
46 Ohio State 89.89% 78.16% 11.73%
47 UC-Irvine 84.40% 72.73% 11.67%
48 Kentucky 82.89% 71.27% 11.62%
49 Georgia 89.06% 77.48% 11.58%
50 Boston College 91.77% 80.30% 11.47%

Continue reading

March 2, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

U.S. News, Department Of Education, And Law Schools Take The Gloves Off In Rankings Battle

Wall Street Journal Op-Ed:  Why Elite Law and Medical Schools Can’t Stand U.S. News, by Eric J. Gertler (Chairman & CEO, U.S. News):

US News Grad Schools (2022)The decision by some elite law and medical schools to opt out of the U.S. News & World Report ranking surveys has ignited a national debate on meritocracy and equity. But lost in this discussion is the reason U.S. News ranks academic institutions and why our rankings are so important to aspiring students. ...

Our rankings don’t capture every nuance. Academic institutions aren’t monolithic or static; comparing them across a common data set can be challenging. But we reject our critics’ paternalistic view that students are somehow incapable of discerning for themselves from this information which school is the best fit.

Moreover, the perspective of elite schools doesn’t fit with that of the broader law- and medical-school community. Our editors held meetings with 110 law deans following the outcry over our rankings. Excepting the top 14 law schools, almost 75% of the schools that submitted surveys in 2022 did so in 2023. For medical schools, the engagement level was higher.

While we know that our rankings are important to students, we’re incredulous that our critics blame our rankings for just about every issue academia confronts. ... [E]lite schools object to our use of a common data set for all schools because our rankings are something they can’t control and they don’t want to be held accountable by an independent third party. ...

By refusing to participate, elite schools are opting out of an important discussion about what constitutes the best education for students, while implying that excellence and important goals like diversity are mutually exclusive.

Is it tolerable to leave schools unaccountable for the education they deliver to students? We think not.

Reuters, U.S. News Rankings Come Under Fire at Yale, Harvard Conference:

The U.S. Secretary of Education on Wednesday criticized annual higher education rankings published by U.S. News and World Report, saying they have "created an unhealthy obsession with selectivity."

Secretary Miguel Cardona was speaking at a conference organized by the law schools at Harvard and Yale universities, amid a backlash over the magazine's influential law school rankings.

“We need a culture change," Cardona said, asserting that U.S. News' emphasis on selectivity and exclusivity has helped steer underserved students to lower-tier institutions. "It’s time to stop worshipping at the false altar of U.S. News & World Report.”

Continue reading

March 2, 2023 in Law Review Rankings, Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, March 1, 2023

Colorado College President (And Former UC-Irvine Law Dean) Song Richardson Withdraws From U.S. News Rankings

Wall Street Journal, Colorado College Withdraws From U.S. News & World Report Undergrad Ranking:

Colorado CollegeColorado College will no longer cooperate with U.S. News & World Report’s ranking of the nation’s best colleges, making it the highest-ranked college to pull out of the undergraduate rankings in decades.

“We have a very strong vision for where we want to go in the future. Those metrics that U.S. News measures are just inconsistent with who we are,” said Colorado College President L. Song Richardson. The school has consistently ranked among the nation’s top 30 liberal-arts colleges by U.S. News & World Report’s measure, landing at No. 27 on the latest list.

Colorado’s withdrawal follows a string of defections by top-ranked law and medical schools since November, signaling that dissatisfaction with the rankings’ methodology and power is continuing to spread.

Continue reading

March 1, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

The Choosiest Law Schools: Wash U Is Top 5, Yale Is No. 1 (Mostly)

ABA Journal, Which Law Schools Are Choosiest? Washington University Is In Top Five, While Yale Is Mostly No. 1:

Yale Law School is No. 1 based on ABA admissions data showing that it is the choosiest law school in terms of acceptance rate and median LSAT scores for fall 2022.

But Yale Law falls to No. 2 in a tie with two other law schools based on the median undergraduate grade-point average of its fall 2022 admittees, according to Paul L. Caron, dean of the Pepperdine University Rick J. Caruso School of Law who published his findings at the TaxProf Blog hereherehere and here. ...

Top 5

Continue reading

March 1, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, February 27, 2023

WSJ: Boycotting Medical Schools, Diversity, And Merit

Wall Street Journal Op-Ed:  Medical Schools Are Wrong to Think Diversity and Merit Are in Conflict, by Fritz François (NYU Medical School) & Gbenga Ogedegbe (NYU Medical School):

U.S. News (2023) (Medical Schools)A growing number of medical schools have announced that they will no longer share data with U.S. News & World Report. These schools claim that the magazine’s annual rankings hinder their ability to increase diversity.

Such claims aren’t supported by evidence. The ranking methodology, as currently constructed, includes consideration of students’ Medical College Admission Test scores and undergraduate grade-point averages, as well as other criteria. But medical schools have always been free to admit anyone they choose, regardless of their rankings. It’s true that diversity isn’t a criterion in the U.S. News methodology, but why should that stop schools from recruiting minority applicants or establishing a campus culture that encourages and values diversity? There is nothing in a thoughtful admissions process that explicitly prevents medical schools from assembling a student body based on anything other than academic performance, holistic reviews and interviews of candidates. ...

Continue reading

February 27, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Saturday, February 25, 2023

The U.S. News Rankings Drama And The Future Of Legal Education

David Lat Podcast, The U.S. News Rankings Drama And The Future Of Legal Education:

US News (2023)In almost thirty years of following the world of U.S. legal education, from applying to law schools in fall 1995 to covering them today as a journalist, I don’t think I have seen as consequential a time as the current one. To explain the whirlwind of recent developments, I sought out two of my favorite observers of the legal academy: Dan Rodriguez, former dean of the Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law, and Anna Ivey, former admissions dean at the University of Chicago Law School.

When I asked them to join me, I selected as our topic the U.S. News law school rankings—specifically, the withdrawal of dozens of schools from the rankings, followed by the announcement of significant revisions to the rankings methodology. But it’s impossible to discuss the rankings in a vacuum, so we wound up having a wide-ranging discussion that touched on two other possible major changes—abandonment of the LSAT (or any other test) as an admissions requirement, and an end to affirmative action—and the future of legal education more generally.

Continue reading

February 25, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, February 23, 2023

Preview Of The 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings: Admissions

US News Logo 2Last month, I summarized the momentous changes coming in the 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings methodology to be released in the spring (the 2023 rankings are here). The 2024 rankings will be based in part on the 2022 admissions data I blogged the last three days. In the current 2023 methodology, law school admissions count 21% in the overall ranking:

Below are two admissions rankings. The first is a simple ranking using the above weights. The second uses Z-scores with the above weights to better approximate the U.S. News methodology.

 

Law

School

Acceptance Rate Rank UPGA Rank LSAT Rank

Weighted Ranks

1 Yale 1 2 1 1.42
2 Harvard 4 6 2 3.76
3 Stanford 2 6 3 4.20
4 Washington Univ. 26 2 6 5.29
5 Chicago 12 9 3 5.93
6 Virginia 10 2 10 6.67
7 Penn 3 10 6 7.52
8 Columbia 7 16 3 8.61
9 NYU 19 15 6 10.37
10 UCLA 18 10 10 10.38
11 Cornell 24 16 6 11.02
12 Northwestern 17 14 10 12.00
13 Vanderbilt 13 10 15 12.82
14 Georgetown 25 21 10 15.30
15 Florida 23 10 20 15.98
16 BYU 56 6 21 16.42
17 Duke 6 23 15 17.90
18 Michigan 11 29 10 17.96
19 USC 9 16 21 18.35
20 Georgia 16 16 21 18.68
21 Alabama 39 1 31 18.88
22 Texas 14 26 15 19.54
23 Boston Univ. 20 26 15 19.82
24 UC-Berkeley 8 29 15 20.50
25 George Washington 36 26 21 23.80
26 Texas A&M 20 5 41 25.00
27 Arizona State 31 23 28 26.06
28 Notre Dame 34 34 21 27.04
29 Minnesota 84 29 21 27.33
30 Emory 40 36 21 28.15
31 George Mason 30 29 31 30.12
32 Florida State 29 29 36 32.75
33 North Carolina 15 38 31 33.15
34 Pepperdine Caruso 41 23 41 33.50
35 Ohio State 83 21 41 34.67
36 Boston College 5 45 31 35.60
37 Utah 57 16 50 36.17
38 Fordham 27 51 28 37.54
39 UC-Irvine 28 51 28 37.58
40 Indiana (Maurer) 105 34 41 41.13
41 Cardozo 68 39 41 41.45
42 William & Mary 116 43 36 42.73
43 Wisconsin 74 48 36 42.81
44 Wake Forest 60 51 36 43.39
45 Villanova 22 39 50 44.08
46 University of Arizona 35 39 50 44.70
47 Illinois 73 60 31 45.08
48 Colorado 55 51 41 45.83
49 UC-Davis 37 64 36 47.71
50 Richmond 66 43 50 47.85

Continue reading

February 23, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Law School Rankings By Fall 2022 Acceptance Rates

Update: Preview Of The 2024 U.S. News Law School Rankings: Admissions

Following up on this week's posts:

Rank School 2022 Acceptance Rate 2021 Acceptance Rate
1 Yale 5.72 4.12 (1)
2 Stanford 6.88 6.28 (2)
3 Penn 9.74 9.39 (4)
4 Harvard 10.06 6.90 (3)
5 Boston College 10.16 23.49 (33)
6 Duke 10.74 14.45 (14)
7 Columbia 11.93 11.42 (7)
8 UC-Berkeley 12.47 13.66 (11)
9 USC 12.70 12.96 (10)
10 Virginia 12.88 9.66 (5)
11 Michigan 13.51 10.65 (6)
12 Chicago 14.24 11.91 (8)
13 Vanderbilt 14.53 14.25 (13)
14 Texas 14.56 15.24 (16)
15 North Carolina 14.61 15.46 (19)
16 Georgia 14.83 18.48 (28)
17 Northwestern 15.05 13.91 (12)
18 UCLA 15.50 15.43 (18)
19 NYU 15.65 14.52 (15)
20 Boston Univ. 16.33 18.33 (26)
20 Texas A&M 16.33 18.41 (27)
22 Villanova 16.47 17.80 (25)
23 Florida 16.94 17.43 (22)
24 Cornell 17.44 15.41 (17)
25 Georgetown 17.64 12.88 (9)
26 Washington Univ. 18.02 15.88 (20)
27 Fordham 18.79 17.69 (24)
28 UC-Irvine 19.45 16.83 (21)
29 Florida State 19.58 22.47 (32)
30 George Mason 19.63 27.07 (42)
31 Arizona State 19.65 20.61 (30)
32 Florida Int'l 22.60 20.56 (29)
33 Baylor 23.87 34.34 (75)
34 Notre Dame 24.58 17.51 (23)
35 University of Arizona 24.93 24.73 (36)
36 George Washington 25.00 21.57 (31)
37 UC-Davis 25.18 28.26 (49)
38 Golden Gate 25.53 51.55 (142)
39 Alabama 25.78 30.96 (60)
40 Emory 26.05 27.31 (43)
41 Pepperdine 27.68 24.97 (37)
42 Connecticut 27.99 28.79 (51)
43 Dayton 28.32 25.76 (40)
44 Georgia State 28.44 26.96 (41)
45 Chapman 28.70 28.26 (50)
46 UC-San Francisco 28.95 28.04 (47)
47 Maryland 29.49 32.77 (70)
48 Hawaii 29.65 32.74 (67)
49 University of Washington 30.29 25.57 (39)
50 Penn State-Univ. Park 30.86 35.64 (77)

Continue reading

February 22, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, February 21, 2023

Law School Rankings By Fall 2022 Median UGPAs

Updates:

Following up on yesterday's post, Law School Rankings By Fall 2022 Median LSAT Scores:

Rank School 2022 UGPA 2021 UGPA
1 Alabama 3.95 3.94 (1)
2 Virginia 3.94 3.91 (5)
2 Washington Univ. 3.94 3.93 (3)
2 Yale 3.94 3.94 (1)
5 Texas A&M 3.93 3.84 (17)
6 BYU 3.92 3.85 (14)
6 Harvard 3.92 3.92 (4)
6 Stanford 3.92 3.91 (5)
9 Chicago 3.91 3.91 (5)
10 UCLA 3.90 3.82 (22)
10 Florida 3.90 3.86 (10)
10 Penn 3.90 3.90 (8)
10 Vanderbilt 3.90 3.89 (9)
14 Northwestern 3.89 3.86 (10)
15 NYU 3.88 3.86 (10)
16 Columbia 3.87 3.84 (17)
16 Cornell 3.87 3.86 (10)
16 Georgia 3.87 3.82 (22)
16 USC 3.87 3.82 (22)
16 Utah 3.87 3.82 (22)
21 Georgetown 3.86 3.85 (14)
21 Ohio State 3.86 3.79 (33)
23 Arizona State 3.85 3.85 (14)
23 Duke 3.85 3.82 (22)
23 Pepperdine 3.85 3.80 (29)
26 Boston Univ. 3.84 3.77 (35)
26 George Washington 3.84 3.83 (20)
26 Texas 3.84 3.80 (29)
29 UC-Berkeley 3.83 3.83 (20)
29 Florida State 3.83 3.82 (22)
29 George Mason 3.83 3.81 (28)
29 Michigan 3.83 3.84 (17)
29 Minnesota 3.83 3.80 (29)
34 Indiana (Maurer) 3.81 3.77 (35)
34 Notre Dame 3.81 3.77 (35)
36 Emory 3.80 3.80 (29)
36 Wayne State 3.80 3.75 (40)
38 North Carolina 3.77 3.73 (43)
39 University of Arizona 3.76 3.66 (62)
39 Cardozo 3.76 3.74 (42)
39 Tennessee 3.76 3.67 (60)
39 Villanova 3.76 3.70 (45)
43 Richmond 3.75 3.70 (45)
43 William & Mary 3.75 3.78 (34)
45 Boston College 3.74 3.69 (53)
45 San Diego 3.74 3.70 (45)
45 UNLV 3.74 3.70 (45)
48 Cincinnati 3.73 3.70 (45)
48 Kansas 3.73 3.69 (53)
48 Wisconsin 3.73 3.65 (65)

Continue reading

February 21, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, February 20, 2023

Law School Rankings By Fall 2022 Median LSAT Scores

Updates:

Rank School 2022 LSAT 2021 LSAT
1 Yale 175 174 (1)
2 Harvard 174 174 (1)
3 Chicago 173 172 (4)
3 Columbia 173 174 (1)
3 Stanford 173 172 (4)
6 Cornell 172 171 (7)
6 NYU 172 172 (4)
6 Penn 172 171 (7)
6 Washington Univ. 172 170 (13)
10 UCLA 171 170 (13)
10 Georgetown 171 171 (7)
10 Michigan 171 171 (7)
10 Northwestern 171 171 (7)
10 Virginia 171 171 (7)
15 Boston Univ. 170 169 (16)
15 UC-Berkeley 170 169 (16)
15 Duke 170 170 (13)
15 Texas 170 169 (16)
15 Vanderbilt 170 169 (16)
20 Florida 169 167 (22)
21 BYU 168 167 (22)
21 Emory 168 167 (22)
21 George Washington 168 167 (22)
21 Georgia 168 166 (27)
21 Minnesota 168 166 (27)
21 Notre Dame 168 168 (20)
21 USC 168 168 (20)
28 Arizona State 167 166 (27)
28 UC-Irvine 167 167 (22)
28 Fordham 167 166 (27)
31 Alabama 166 165 (31)
31 Boston College 166 165 (31)
31 George Mason 166 164 (34)
31 Illinois 166 164 (34)
31 North Carolina 166 164 (34)
36 UC-Davis 165 165 (31)
36 Florida State 165 163 (45)
36 Wake Forest 165 163 (45)
36 William & Mary 165 164 (34)
36 Wisconsin 165 164 (34)
41 Cardozo 164 164 (34)
41 Colorado 164 164 (34)
41 Indiana (Maurer) 164 164 (34)
41 Ohio State 164 163 (45)
41 Pepperdine 164 164 (34)
41 SMU 164 163 (45)
41 Texas A&M 164 163 (45)
41 Washington & Lee 164 164 (34)
41 University of Washington 164 164 (34)
50 University of Arizona 163 163 (45)
50 Baylor 163 162 (54)
50 Iowa 163 163 (45)
50 Maryland 163 161 (61)
50 Northeastern 163 162 (54)
50 Richmond 163 162 (54)
50 Temple 163 163 (45)
50 Utah 163 163 (45)
50 Villanova 163 162 (54)

Continue reading

February 20, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, February 16, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Yesterday, I blogged the Top 50 law school professor rankings, giving equal weight (50%) to the Professors: Teaching and Professors: Accessibility rankings.

Today, in my concluding post, I blog the Princeton Review's overall law school rankings, giving equal weight (20%) to each of the Admissions Selectivity, Academic Experience, Professors: Teaching, Professors: Accessibility, and Career Rating rankings:

Continue reading

February 16, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, February 15, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Professors (Teaching And Accessibility)

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Here are the Top 50 law school professor rankings, giving equal weight (50%) to the Professors: Teaching and Professors: Accessibility rankings:

Continue reading

February 15, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, February 14, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Career Rating

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Career Rating:  This rating measures the confidence students have in their school's ability to lead them to fruitful employment opportunities, as well as the school's own record of having done so. This rating takes into account both student survey responses and school-reported statistical data. We ask students about how much the law program encourages practical experience; the opportunities for externships, internships, and clerkships; and how prepared to practice law they expect to feel after graduating. We ask law schools for the median starting salaries of graduating students; the percentage employed in a job that requires bar passage (and not employed by the school); and the percentage of these students who pass the bar exam the first time they take it. This rating is on a scale of 60–99.

Continue reading

February 14, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, February 13, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Professors (Accessibility)

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Professors: Accessible:  This rating is based on how law students rate the accessibility of law faculty members at their school. The rating is on a scale of 60 to 99. 

Continue reading

February 13, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Saturday, February 11, 2023

With Connecticut And Pittsburgh, 42 Law Schools Are Boycotting The U.S. News Rankings

US News (2023)

  U.S. News Rank
Boycott (42)
Yale 1
Stanford 2
Columbia 4
Harvard 4
Penn 6
NYU 7
Virginia 8
UC-Berkeley 9
Michigan 10
Duke 11
Northwestern 13
Georgetown 14
UCLA 15
Vanderbilt 17
Fordham 37
UC-Davis 37
UC-Irvine 37
Wisconsin 43
Maryland 47
University of Washington 49
UC-San Francisco 51
Tulane 55
Penn State-Dickinson 58
Penn State-Univ. Park 64
Connecticut 64
Pittsburgh 78
St. John's 84
Rutgers 86
New Hampshire 105
Gonzaga 116
Seattle 116
Creighton 139
Idaho 142
Cal-Western 147-192
Campbell 147-192
John Marshall (GA) 147-192
Quinnipiac 147-192
Roger Williams 147-192
San Francisco 147-192
South Texas 147-192
Southwestern 147-192
Western Michigan 147-192
No Boycott (53)
Chicago 3
Cornell 12
Washington Univ. 16
Florida 21
Georgia 29
George Mason 30
Arizona 45
Colorado 49
SMU 58
San Diego 64
Kentucky 67
Seton Hall 73
Case Western 78
South Carolina 84
Cincinnati 88
Louisville 94
Indiana (McKinney) 98
Louisiana State* 105
Texas Tech 105
Washburn 105
Drake 111
Mississippi 111
Stetson 111
Missouri-Kansas City* 114
Chapman 118
Hofstra 118
West Virginia 118
Baltimore 122
Mercer 122
Suffolk 122
Cleveland-Marshall 127
Willamette 129
Wyoming 129
Pacific 133
South Dakota 133
Regent 142
Akron 147-192
Arkansas-Little Rock 147-192
Ave Maria 147-192
Elon 147-192
Faulkner 147-192
John Marshall (IL) 147-192
Liberty 147-192
Lincoln Memorial 147-192
Mississippi College 147-192
North Dakota 147-192
Nova 147-192
Ohio Northern* 147-192
Oklahoma City 147-192
Southern Illinois 147-192
St. Mary's 147-192
Toledo 147-192
Western New England 147-192

*Will answer some but not all questions

Continue reading

February 11, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Friday, February 10, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Professors (Teaching)

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Professors: Interesting:  This rating is based on how students rate the quality of teaching at their law school. This rating is on a scale of 60-99.

Continue reading

February 10, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, February 9, 2023

Will The Boycott Actually Strengthen The U.S. News Rankings?

Chronicle of Higher Education, How Criticism Actually Strengthens Rankings:

U.S. News Generic (2020)Why do college rankings endure? In a paper published last month, two German sociologists, Julian Hamann and Leopold Ringel, put forth a provocative hypothesis: that criticism ultimately strengthens rankers, who respond by modifying their work rather than abandoning it, which ends up reinforcing their legitimacy [The Discursive Resilience of University Rankings]. It’s like having the same argument with your spouse over who should do the dishes. In the end, it just reaffirms each of your places in the relationship.

Hamann and Ringel’s idea is especially relevant now. Over the past three months, dozens of law and medical schools have announced they will no longer cooperate with U.S. News & World Report on its rankings. The collective exodus gave law- and medical-school deans an opportunity to air their grievances with ranked lists in a high-profile way. ...

It’s been academe’s biggest protest of rankings in years. Yet could the ultimate critique — leaving the rankings — end up cementing rankers’ place in higher education? The Chronicle spoke with Hamann, a junior professor at Humboldt University of Berlin, and Ringel, a postdoctoral researcher at Bielefeld University, about how they interpret the current discontent with rankings, higher ed’s role in the rankings process, and how change could really happen. ...

Boycotting the ranking, that’s what law and medical schools in the U.S. did to U.S. News. Would you say that was an effective way of weakening the rankings?

Continue reading

February 9, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Academic Experience

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton Review

I previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Academic Experience:  This rating measures the quality of the school's learning environment on a scale of 60 to 99. Factors taken into consideration include the Admissions Selectivity Rating, as well as how students rate each of the following: the quality of teaching and the accessibility of their professors, the research resources at their school, the range of available courses, the balance of curricular emphasis on legal theory and practical lawyering, the tolerance for diverse opinions in the classroom, and the degree of intellectual challenge that the coursework presents.

Continue reading

February 9, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, February 8, 2023

2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Admissions Selectivity

Update: 2023 Princeton Review Law School Rankings: Overall Ranking

Princeton ReviewI previously blogged the lists of the Top 5 law schools in fourteen categories in the 2023 edition of the Princeton Review's Best Law Schools. In a series of posts, I will highlight the Top 50 schools in the five categories for which the Princeton Review provides individual law school data:

Admissions Selectivity:  This rating measures the competitiveness of admissions at each law school on a scale of 60–99. Factors taken into consideration include the median LSAT score and undergraduate GPA of entering 1L students, the percentage of applicants who are accepted, and the percentage of applicants who are accepted and ultimately enroll. 

Continue reading

February 8, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Saturday, February 4, 2023

In Defense Of The U.S. News Law School Rankings

Kenneth Terrell (Princeton Alumni Weekend), Why College Rankings Remain Important, If Flawed:

US News (2023)Yale’s recent announcement that it would no longer “participate” in the U.S. News rankings of law schools — despite its place at the top of that list — has renewed talk that the era of these annual lists might be coming to an end, especially when 10 other law schools quickly announced they also would no longer cooperate with the publication. These institutions argue that the criteria U.S. News uses hurts their ability to enroll students of color, students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, and those who might want to pursue careers in public service. ...

I believe the rankings are an important, if imperfect tool, for students and families. ...

To improve the education and career outcomes of students in law schools — particularly those who are from lower-income backgrounds, first in their family to go to college, students of color, or all of the above — commitments to meaningful change would be more effective than announcements about withdrawing from rankings.

Continue reading

February 4, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Friday, February 3, 2023

Is U.S. News In Trouble?

Observer, U.S. News Depends On its College Rankings. What Happens When Universities Don’t Want To Be Ranked?:

U.S. News Generic (2020)

In the past few months, numerous high-ranked universities have dropped out of the U.S. News & World Report rankings, spelling trouble for the future of the nearly 80-year old publication.

For decades, schools, deans and even students have called for an overhaul of the annual U.S. News & World Report university rankings, to no avail.

But in the past few months, a series of public statements from top-ranked universities has begun to finally pose a real threat to U.S. News, which has been the dominant player in the rankings industry for nearly 40 years. ...

Continue reading

February 3, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, February 2, 2023

Two Perspectives On The Growing U.S. News Rankings Boycott

Wall Street Journal Op-Ed:  Medical Schools Bail on Academic Merit and Intellectual Rigor, by Ira Stoll (Education Next):

U.S. News Generic (2020)To see how the diversity, equity and inclusion mania is colliding with meritocracy in American higher education, pay attention to the flap over graduate schools pulling out of the U.S. News rankings. Readers who aren’t applying to medical school may have missed the controversy. But anyone who plans on seeing a doctor or benefiting from research or treatment at an academic medical center has an interest in the outcome.

So far, U.S. News has resisted demands from the graduate schools to base the rankings on equity rather than on the grades and test scores of incoming students. U.S. News has been transparent about the method it uses for its rankings, including factors such as a reputation survey, MCAT scores and grade point averages of incoming students.

The medical schools have been similarly clear about why they disagree with the U.S. News method and will stop participating. The Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, in a Jan. 24 statement, said the U.S. News rankings undermine the school’s “commitment to anti-racism” and “outreach to diverse communities.” ...

Continue reading

February 2, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Tuesday, January 31, 2023

Princeton Review's Best 168 Law Schools (2023 Edition)

Princeton-reviewThe Princeton Review has published the 2023 edition of The Best 168 Law Schools (press release) (FAQs) (methodology):

The company reports its annual law school rankings in 14 categories: each one lists the top 10 ranking schools. ...

The Princeton Review’s law school rankings are uniquely based on data the company gathers from surveys of administrators at the law schools as well as surveys of students attending the schools who rate and report on their experiences at them. The rankings for 2023 are based on surveys of administrators at 168 law schools in 2021-22 and surveys of 17,000 students enrolled in the schools [an average of 101 per school] over the past three academic years.

More than 60 data points are factored into the company’s ranking list tallies. Of the 14 categories of ranking lists, six lists are based on student- and administrator-reported data. Five are based solely on student data, and three are based solely on administrator data.

Best Quality of Life: Based on student answers to survey questions on: whether there is a strong sense of community at the school whether differing opinions are tolerated in the classroom, the location of the school, the quality of social life at the school, the school's research resources (library, computer and database resources). 

  1. Virginia
  2. Florida State
  3. Vanderbilt
  4. UCLA
  5. Penn

Best Professors:  Based on student answers to survey questions concerning how good their professors are as teachers and how accessible they are outside the classroom.

  1. Chicago
  2. Duke
  3. Stanford
  4. Virginia
  5. Vanderbilt

Continue reading

January 31, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, January 30, 2023

WSJ: Rebellion Over U.S. News Rankings Seems Likely To Fail

Wall Street Journal, Rebellion Over College Rankings Seems Likely to Fail:

WSJIn the past two weeks, Harvard, Stanford and Columbia universities, the University of Pennsylvania and the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai said they would stop cooperating with U.S. News & World Report’s medical-school rankings.

That followed the decision last year by universities including Yale, Georgetown, Harvard, Stanford, Columbia and California, Berkeley to quit cooperating on the publication’s law-school rankings.

Critics are cheering the exodus from a process they say leads students to focus on external prestige rather than education quality and encourages schools to game rankings at the expense of students. The schools that are withdrawing say the rankings are elitist, and penalize institutions that admit strong candidates without high test scores.

“In the 40 years of rankings, this is the biggest shock to the system—that gives me hope,” said Colin Diver, a former president of Reed College, which has long abstained from the U.S. News ranking. Mr. Diver is the author of “Breaking Ranks: How the Rankings Industry Rules Higher Education and What to Do About It.”

But hopes that this marks the death knell for college rankings are likely to be in vain. The reality is that what the schools themselves contribute to the rankings is relatively small: The data includes test scores, alumni giving, financial information and so on. But most of the data used to determine the rankings can be derived from publicly available information, or surveys conducted by U.S. News itself. Indeed, U.S. News has revised the survey over the years in response to criticism. There is a case to be made that the less the schools contribute, the more objective the rankings might become, in some respects. ...

Continue reading

January 30, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Saturday, January 28, 2023

With Vanderbilt, Wisconsin, Tulane, And Creighton, 40 Law Schools Are Boycotting The U.S. News Rankings

US News (2023)

  U.S. News Rank
Boycott (40)
Yale 1
Stanford 2
Columbia 4
Harvard 4
Penn 6
NYU 7
Virginia 8
UC-Berkeley 9
Michigan 10
Duke 11
Northwestern 13
Georgetown 14
UCLA 15
Vanderbilt 17
Fordham 37
UC-Davis 37
UC-Irvine 37
Wisconsin 43
Maryland 47
University of Washington 49
UC-San Francisco 51
Tulane 55
Penn State-Dickinson 58
Penn State-Univ. Park 64
St. John's 84
Rutgers 86
New Hampshire 105
Gonzaga 116
Seattle 116
Creighton 139
Idaho 142
Cal-Western 147-192
Campbell 147-192
John Marshall (GA) 147-192
Quinnipiac 147-192
Roger Williams 147-192
San Francisco 147-192
South Texas 147-192
Southwestern 147-192
Western Michigan 147-192
No Boycott (53)
Chicago 3
Cornell 12
Washington Univ. 16
Florida 21
Georgia 29
George Mason 30
Arizona 45
Colorado 49
SMU 58
San Diego 64
Kentucky 67
Seton Hall 73
Case Western 78
South Carolina 84
Cincinnati 88
Louisville 94
Indiana (McKinney) 98
Louisiana State* 105
Texas Tech 105
Washburn 105
Drake 111
Mississippi 111
Stetson 111
Missouri-Kansas City* 114
Chapman 118
Hofstra 118
West Virginia 118
Baltimore 122
Mercer 122
Suffolk 122
Cleveland-Marshall 127
Willamette 129
Wyoming 129
Pacific 133
South Dakota 133
Regent 142
Akron 147-192
Arkansas-Little Rock 147-192
Ave Maria 147-192
Elon 147-192
Faulkner 147-192
John Marshall (IL) 147-192
Liberty 147-192
Lincoln Memorial 147-192
Mississippi College 147-192
North Dakota 147-192
Nova 147-192
Ohio Northern* 147-192
Oklahoma City 147-192
Southern Illinois 147-192
St. Mary's 147-192
Toledo 147-192
Western New England 147-192

*Will answer some but not all questions

Continue reading

January 28, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Justice Kavanaugh Says U.S. News Law School Rankings Are 'Very Problematic'; Peer Reputation Is 'Kind Of A Joke'

Reuters, Justice Kavanaugh Rips U.S. News Rankings As 'Highly Problematic' At Law School Talk

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh has joined the growing chorus of U.S. News & World Report law school rankings critics, saying during a talk this week at the University of Notre Dame Law School that the annual list fails to accurately gauge which schools are providing the best legal education.

“I think they’re based on things, from what I understand, that are very amorphous, very subjective, very word of mouth factors that don’t correlate well with the education that you’re actually receiving, and I find them highly problematic,” Kavanaugh said during a Monday panel with law dean Marcus Cole, a video of which the school released on Thursday. ...

U.S. News has said it will continue to rank law schools despite the boycott and that is modifying its methodology to rely only on publicly available data supplied annually by the American Bar Association, which accredits law schools. It will no longer include expenditures-per-student, a metric that has been criticized as rewarding schools for driving up tuition, among other changes.

But the revamped rankings will still assign each school a “reputation score” derived from surveys of legal academics, judges and practicing lawyers. Kavanaugh called the reputation scores “kind of a joke,” adding that most people don’t have enough knowledge about different law schools to effectively rank them. He added that he does not consider law school rank when hiring clerks.

Continue reading

January 28, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, January 26, 2023

With Gonzaga, Quinnipiac, Rutgers, And Seattle, 36 Law Schools Are Boycotting The U.S. News Rankings

Updated U.S. News Law School Rankings Boycott Scorecard

US News (2023)

  U.S. News Rank
Boycott (36)
Yale 1
Stanford 2
Columbia 4
Harvard 4
Penn 6
NYU 7
Virginia 8
UC-Berkeley 9
Michigan 10
Duke 11
Northwestern 13
Georgetown 14
UCLA 15
Fordham 37
UC-Davis 37
UC-Irvine 37
Maryland 47
University of Washington 49
UC-San Francisco 51
Penn State-Dickinson 58
Penn State-Univ. Park 64
St. John's 84
Rutgers 86
New Hampshire 105
Gonzaga 116
Seattle 116
Idaho 142
Cal-Western 147-192
Campbell 147-192
John Marshall (GA) 147-192
Quinnipiac 147-192
Roger Williams 147-192
San Francisco 147-192
South Texas 147-192
Southwestern 147-192
Western Michigan 147-192
No Boycott (53)
Chicago 3
Cornell 12
Washington Univ. 16
Florida 21
Georgia 29
George Mason 30
Arizona 45
Colorado 49
SMU 58
San Diego 64
Kentucky 67
Seton Hall 73
Case Western 78
South Carolina 84
Cincinnati 88
Louisville 94
Indiana (McKinney) 98
Louisiana State* 105
Texas Tech 105
Washburn 105
Drake 111
Mississippi 111
Stetson 111
Missouri-Kansas City* 114
Chapman 118
Hofstra 118
West Virginia 118
Baltimore 122
Mercer 122
Suffolk 122
Cleveland-Marshall 127
Willamette 129
Wyoming 129
Pacific 133
South Dakota 133
Regent 142
Akron 147-192
Arkansas-Little Rock 147-192
Ave Maria 147-192
Elon 147-192
Faulkner 147-192
John Marshall (IL) 147-192
Liberty 147-192
Lincoln Memorial 147-192
Mississippi College 147-192
North Dakota 147-192
Nova 147-192
Ohio Northern* 147-192
Oklahoma City 147-192
Southern Illinois 147-192
St. Mary's 147-192
Toledo 147-192
Western New England 147-192

*Will answer some but not all questions

Continue reading

January 26, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

How Diversity Is Lingering Over The LSAT And U.S. News Law School Rankings

How Diversity Is Lingering Over the LSAT and U.S. News & World Report Rankings, Nat'l Jurist, Winter 2023, at 4:

An ABA committee has recommended that standardized tests — most notably the LSAT — be optional for law school admission. Critics say schools place too much emphasis on it, and Black and Hispanic test-takers don’t perform as well on it as their white counterparts. ...

At the same time, a number of the nation’s most prestigious law schools are opting out of the much-hyped U.S. News & World Report rankings, blasting the assessment for a host of wrongs. Some say schools are boosting their positions in the rankings by admitting top students at the expense of those from disadvantaged backgrounds. Love ’em or hate ’em, the ranking affects both school and student behavior. ...

What’s caused such upheaval in such a short time?

Some say law schools are preparing for the U.S. Supreme Court to strike down — or seriously weaken — the ability of schools to use affirmative action practices in their admissions decisions. If that happens, schools will need to pivot and not be as dependent on such concrete metrics as the LSAT. If they continue the current course, it could gut diversity. The high court, which heard arguments last October, is expected to rule in June.

Continue reading

January 26, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

The Clash And The U.S. News Law School Rankings: Should I Stay Or Should I Go?

Lolita Buckner Inniss (Dean, Colorado), Should I Stay or Should I Go?, 26 Green Bag 2D 19 (2023):

US News (2023)During the fall and winter of 2022-2023, several United States law schools withdrew from participation in the U.S. News & World Report survey of law schools. For over three decades the survey ranked law schools, and in doing so, has become an increasingly influential arbiter of law school quality. Law schools, however, have argued that the survey fails to assess the nature and quality of schools fully or accurately, and for that reason many have ceased to participate--they are the “goers.” Other schools have chosen to continue participating; these are the “stayers.” While goers seem to have garnered news headlines as heroic, autonomy-embracing figures, it is worth considering whether the choice of going, or staying for that matter, will meaningfully alter how law schools are viewed. The world of law, and law schools, has long been governed by entrenched hierarchies and markers of status that exist well beyond the U.S. News & World Report survey.

Continue reading

January 25, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

The 50 Most Downloaded U.S. Law Professors Of 2022

Ssrn

Rank Name School Downloads
1 Cass Sunstein Harvard 43,282
2 Daniel Solove George Washington 28,479
3 Lucian Bebchuk Harvard 27,727
4 Mark Lemley Stanford 21,131
5 Orin Kerr UC-Berkeley 19,608
6 Roberto Tallarita Harvard 15,229
7 Brian Frye Kentucky 14,991
8 Bernard Black Northwestern 13,599
9 Brandon Hasbrouck Washington & Lee 13,456
10 Danielle Keats Citron Virginia 13,417
11 Greer Donley Pittsburgh 12,490
12 Herbert Hovenkamp Penn 12,086
13 Rachel Rebouché Temple 11,833
14 Reuven Avi-Yonah Michigan 11,679
15 David Cohen Drexel 11,670
16 Brian Leiter Chicago 11,411
17 J. Mark Ramseyer Harvard 10,743
18 Stephen Bainbridge UCLA 10,708
19 Dan Kahan Yale 10,527
20 Mitu Gulati Virginia 10,472
21 Michael Klausner Stanford 10,252
22 Adrian Vermeule Harvard 9,420
23 Michael Ohlrogge NYU 9,375
24 Woodrow Hartzog Boston University 9,236
25 Wulf Kaal St. Thomas-MN 9,202
26 Eric Posner Chicago 8,967
27 Eric Goldman Santa Clara 8,819
28 Richard Albert Texas 8,522
29 Kevin Tobia Georgetown 8,160
30 Richard Leo San Francisco 8,154
31 David Kopel Denver 8,023
32 Neil Richards Washington University 7,890
33 Chris Brummer Georgetown 7,886
34 Hilary Allen American 7,588
35 Peter Menell UC-Berkeley 7,584

Continue reading

January 25, 2023 in Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Ed Scholarship, Legal Education | Permalink

Monday, January 23, 2023

U.S. News Law School Rankings Boycott Scorecard (Updated)

Updated U.S. News Law School Rankings Boycott Scorecard

ABA Journal, US News Extends Rankings Survey Deadline; Which Law Schools Will File?:

After years of complaints about the U.S. News & World Report’s law school rankings, some deans started announcing in November that they would not respond to the publication’s annual survey. And they were not swayed to opt back in when methodology changes were shared this month.

U.S. News recently extended the survey deadline to Jan. 27. The ABA Journal asked all ABA-accredited law schools whether they planned to submit the survey. Out of the 110 schools that responded, 25 said they would not, and 22 were undecided. A chart with the information can be seen here.

The table below includes the responses to the ABA Journal as well as public announcements by law schools:

  U.S. News Rank
Boycott (32)
Yale 1
Stanford 2
Columbia 4
Harvard 4
Penn 6
NYU 7
Virginia 8
UC-Berkeley 9
Michigan 10
Duke 11
Northwestern 13
Georgetown 14
UCLA 15
Fordham 37
UC-Davis 37
UC-Irvine 37
Maryland 47
University of Washington 49
UC-San Francisco 51
Penn State-Dickinson 58
Penn State-Univ. Park 64
St. John's 84
New Hampshire 105
Idaho 142
Cal-Western 147-192
Campbell 147-192
John Marshall (GA) 147-192
Roger Williams 147-192
San Francisco 147-192
South Texas 147-192
Southwestern 147-192
Western Michigan 147-192
No Boycott (53)
Chicago 3
Cornell 12
Washington Univ. 16
Florida 21
Georgia 29
George Mason 30
Arizona 45
Colorado 49
SMU 58
San Diego 64
Kentucky 67
Seton Hall 73
Case Western 78
South Carolina 84
Cincinnati 88
Louisville 94
Indiana (McKinney) 98
Louisiana State* 105
Texas Tech 105
Washburn 105
Drake 111
Mississippi 111
Stetson 111
Missouri-Kansas City* 114
Chapman 118
Hofstra 118
West Virginia 118
Baltimore 122
Mercer 122
Suffolk 122
Cleveland-Marshall 127
Willamette 129
Wyoming 129
Pacific 133
South Dakota 133
Regent 142
Akron 147-192
Arkansas-Little Rock 147-192
Ave Maria 147-192
Elon 147-192
Faulkner 147-192
John Marshall (IL) 147-192
Liberty 147-192
Lincoln Memorial 147-192
Mississippi College 147-192
North Dakota 147-192
Nova 147-192
Ohio Northern* 147-192
Oklahoma City 147-192
Southern Illinois 147-192
St. Mary's 147-192
Toledo 147-192
Western New England 147-192

*Will answer some but not all questions

Continue reading

January 23, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Will The U.S. News Law School Rankings Arms Race Resume In Three Years?

ABA Journal, US News Extends Rankings Survey Deadline; Which Law Schools Will File?:

US News (2023)U.S. News posted a letter Jan. 2 explaining that schools not submitting surveys would still be included in the rankings. Those metrics will focus on public data from the ABA Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar, which is responsible for law school accreditation. Schools that submit surveys will have more detailed profiles, the letter said.

Last week, the publication informed deans about further modifications, including eliminating employment rates, average debt at graduation and spending on instruction from rankings criteria, according to a Jan. 13 letter shared on TaxProf Blog. ...

People may care less about the rankings this year because of the methodological changes, says Mike Spivey, a law school admissions consultant.

“But I’d bet that three years from now, we’re right back to the rankings arms race. As much as people want to say the rankings are horrible and flawed, academics and prospective students are very much interested in what their schools ranked,” he adds.

Continue reading

January 23, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Thursday, January 19, 2023

Texas Tech Law School Informs U.S. News Of 'Substantial' Misstatement Of Its Student Loan Data The Past Three Years

Texas Tech Law School informed U.S. News today that it submitted incorrect data on the average debt of its graduates for each of the past three years:

Texas Tech LogoThe error was originated three years ago by the main campus Office for Student Financial Aid and Scholarships, which collects this data for the Law School. The Law School relies reasonably and in good faith on our campus partners in Financial Aid to collect accurate data for us for our rankings purposes. We were very surprised and disappointed to learn that we received inaccurate data from this office under its prior leadership. ...

As Dean, I take full responsibility for the Law School’s failure to uncover the Office of Student Financial Aid’s reporting errors and ensure a correction before the Law School in turn reported incorrect data to US News. In particular, I should have implemented a more extensive and systematic set of review procedures for this area, which would have uncovered the error, and placed less reliance on the Office of Student Financial Aid’s review process and reports.

The misreport on this metric was substantial. The corrected debt numbers are the following: For 2019, the correct average debt number was $98,695, and the incorrect reported number was $62,583. For 2020, the correct average debt number was $86,023, and the incorrect reported number was $56,898. For 2021, last year, the correct average debt number was $85,956, and the incorrect reported number was $60,088. While these numbers were misreported to US News, they were never directly marketed to applicants by the Law School. We also remain a lower debt law school, and our corrected debt number for 2021 is still well below the national average for debt and a lower number than all but one of the other law schools in this state reporting average debt to US News.

Continue reading

January 19, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

With Maryland, USF, And South Texas, 28 Schools Are Now Boycotting The U.S. News Law School Rankings

Updated U.S. News Law School Rankings Boycott Scorecard

Maryland Carey Law Remains Focused on True Excellence:

Maryland (2016)After a great deal of thoughtful discussion with a wide variety of stakeholders, Maryland Carey Law has made the decision not to provide U.S. News & World Report (USNWR) with proprietary data about the institution in connection with USNWR’s Best Law Schools rankings, scheduled to be published this spring. As one of the oldest and most innovative law schools in the country, Maryland Carey Law has long provided students with the highest quality legal education -- one that trains them to become talented, ethical lawyers who care about justice. We will continue to do this work in the months and years to come.

We applaud USNWR’s willingness to reevaluate its flawed rankings methodology. In light of the company’s decision to rank all law schools on publicly available data only, Maryland Carey Law does not see the need to voluntarily provide additional institutional data for USNWR to sell. We look forward to working in good faith with USNWR in the years to come to arrive at a rankings methodology that more accurately reflects the wide range of values embraced by individual law schools, including fulfilling the aspirations and needs of the diverse range of students we all attract and educate. In the meantime, Maryland Carey Law will remain focused upon the excellence of its faculty, staff, and students, and upon its valued partnerships with the university, the city, the state, and beyond.

USF Law Will No Longer Provide Data to U.S. News:

Continue reading

January 19, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Wednesday, January 18, 2023

Muller Models And Projects Forthcoming U.S. News Law School Rankings

Derek Muller (Iowa; Google Scholar), Modeling and Projecting USNWR Law School Rankings Under New Methodologies:

First, the criteria. USNWR disclosed that it would no longer use privately-collected data and instead rely exclusively on publicly-available data, with the exception of its reputational survey data. (You can see what Dean Paul Caron has aggregated on the topic for more.) It’s not clear whether USNWR will rely on public data other than the ABA data. It’s also not clear whether it will introduce new metrics. It’s given some indications that it will reduce the weight of the reputational survey data, and it will increase the weight of output metrics. ...

Muller Models

One last step was to offer a potential high-low range among the rankings. For each of the five models, I gave each school a rank one step up and one step down, to suggest some degree of uncertainty in how USNWR calculates, for instance, the 10-month employment positions, or diploma privilege admission for bar passage, among other things. That gave me 15 potential rankings—a low, projected, and high among each of the five models. I took the lowest of the low and the highest of the high for a projected range. With high degrees of uncertainty, this range is an important caveat.

Below are my projections.

Continue reading

January 18, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink

Law School Rankings Revolt Spreads To Medical Schools: #1 Harvard Will Not Send Data To U.S. News

Harvard Medical School, HMS Withdraws From U.S. News & World Report Rankings:

Harvard Medical School LogoFollowing careful consideration and consultation with colleagues and stakeholders across Harvard Medical School and beyond, I write today to announce that HMS will no longer submit data to U.S. News & World Report (USNWR) to support their “best medical schools” survey and rankings. ...

I have contemplated this decision since becoming dean six years ago. The courageous and bold moves by my respected colleague Dean John Manning of Harvard Law School and those of peer law schools compelled me to act on behalf of Harvard Medical School. What matters most to me as dean, alumnus, and faculty member is not a #1 ranking, but the quality and richness of the educational experience we provide at Harvard Medical School that encourages personal growth and lifelong learning.

Continue reading

January 18, 2023 in Law School Rankings, Legal Ed News, Legal Ed Rankings, Legal Education | Permalink