Paul L. Caron
Dean



Tuesday, September 8, 2020

Academics Are Really, Really Worried About Their Freedom

The Atlantic:  Academics Are Really, Really Worried About Their Freedom, by John McWhorter (Columbia):

AtlanticOur national reckoning on race has brought to the fore a loose but committed assemblage of people given to the idea that social justice must be pursued via attempts to banish from the public sphere, as much as possible, all opinions that they interpret as insufficiently opposed to power differentials. Valid intellectual and artistic endeavor must hold the battle against white supremacy front and center, white people are to identify and expunge their complicity in this white supremacy with the assumption that this task can never be completed, and statements questioning this program constitute a form of “violence” that merits shaming and expulsion.

Skeptics have labeled this undertaking “cancel culture,” which of late has occasioned a pushback from its representatives. The goal, they suggest, is less to eliminate all signs of a person’s existence—which tends to be impractical anyway— than to supplement critique with punishment of some kind. Thus a group of linguists in July submitted to the Linguistic Society of America a petition not only to criticize the linguist and psychologist Steven Pinker for views they considered racist and sexist, but to have him stripped of his Linguistic Society of America fellow status and removed from the organization’s website listing linguist consultants available to the media. An indication of how deeply this frame of mind has penetrated many of our movers and shakers is that they tend to see this punishment clause as self-evidently just, as opposed to the novel, censorious addendum that it is. ...

[T]he Heterodox Academy conducted an internal member survey of 445 academics. “Imagine expressing your views about a controversial issue while at work, at a time when faculty, staff, and/or other colleagues were present. To what extent would you worry about the following consequences?” To the hypothetical “My reputation would be tarnished,” 32.68 percent answered “very concerned” and 27.27 percent answered “extremely concerned.” To the hypothetical “My career would be hurt,” 24.75 percent answered “very concerned” and 28.68 percent answered “extremely concerned.” In other words, more than half the respondents consider expressing views beyond a certain consensus in an academic setting quite dangerous to their career trajectory.

So no one should feign surprise or disbelief that academics write to me with great frequency to share their anxieties. In a three-week period early this summer, I counted some 150 of these messages. And what they reveal is a very rational culture of fear among those who dissent, even slightly, with the tenets of the woke left.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2020/09/academics-are-really-really-worried-about-their-freedom.html

Legal Ed News, Legal Education | Permalink

Comments

Well most professors are left leaning. They opened pandora's box by fostering hard left views among their students while criticizing conservative views. Now they are becoming victims of their own students' ideology.

Posted by: Chris | Sep 9, 2020 2:02:10 PM

I'm reminded of the original Westworld film. These academics created an environment that was bound to malfunction. I'd be worried, too, but of course, I work for a living in the private sector. We place more emphasis on environments that are conducive to productivity, rather than ideological bubbles detached from reality.

Posted by: MM Classic | Sep 11, 2020 7:44:49 PM