Paul L. Caron

Monday, June 15, 2020

NY Times: Economics, Dominated By White Men, Is Roiled By Black Lives Matter

New York Times, Economics, Dominated by White Men, Is Roiled by Black Lives Matter:

The national protests seeking an end to systemic discrimination against black Americans have given new fuel to a racial reckoning in economics, a discipline dominated by white men despite decades of efforts to open greater opportunity for women and nonwhite men.

A growing chorus of economists is seeking to dislodge the editor of a top academic publication, the University of Chicago economist Harald Uhlig, after he criticized the Black Lives Matter organization on Twitter and equated its members with “flat earthers” over their embrace of calls to defund police departments.

Days earlier, the profession’s de facto governing body, the American Economic Association, sent a letter to its members supporting protesters and saying that “we have only begun to understand racism and its impact on our profession and our discipline.” A group of economists, mostly from outside academia, last week hosted an online fund-raising effort for the Sadie Collective, an organization that aims to bring more black women into the field.

Black economists say the events have brought some progress to a field that has long struggled with discrimination in its ranks — and with a refusal by many of its leaders to acknowledge discrimination in the country at large. But the profession remains nowhere close to a full-scale shift on racial issues: On Wednesday, the director of the White House National Economic Council, Larry Kudlow, told reporters, “I don’t believe there is systemic racism in the U.S.”

Black Americans are vastly underrepresented among economics students and professors, a wide range of data have shown. There are no black editors of the most prestigious economics journals. There are no black professors in the main economics department at Chicago, Mr. Uhlig’s employer, which is one of the most storied departments in the country.

In a survey of economists released by the American Economic Association last year, only 14 percent of black economists agreed with the statement that “people of my race/ethnicity are respected within the field.”

As protests against discrimination have grown in recent days, a conversation has erupted — often led by black economists — over how the lack of diversity has left the profession ill equipped for a moment where policymakers are seeking ideas on how to combat racial inequality in policing, employment and other areas.

Prior TaxProf Blog coverage:

Legal Ed News, Legal Education | Permalink


Prof. Glenn Loury would definitely have something to say about this sophomoric argument masquerading as straight news.

However, it's a simple matter to remedy. I'm waiting for Paul Krugman to step down from his positions to make room for economists of color. Until then, sorry, not buying the sanctimony from so-called liberals.

Posted by: MM | Jun 15, 2020 6:49:54 PM

I think we can expect an attack on the whole concept of merit by every conceivable group now. I’m thinking of arguing that balding, 55-plus men are discriminated against. Wait, isn’t that Trump?

Posted by: Mike Livingston | Jun 15, 2020 2:53:31 AM