Paul L. Caron

Friday, September 6, 2019

From Each According to His Ability?: An Analysis Of Endowment Taxation And Potential Earnings

Erick Sam (Duke University, Department of Philosophy), From Each According to His Ability?: An Analysis of Endowment Taxation and Potential Earnings:

This Article analyzes and critiques “ability taxation”, which taxes a person's "potential earnings." Despite this regime’s longstanding favor as a theoretical ideal for fair and efficient taxation among economists, certain philosophers and tax law scholars, little effort has been made to analyze what “potential earnings” means. This Article explores competing understandings of this notion. In so doing, it unearths a tension at the core of the ability tax program, involving a fundamental misalignment between the metaphysics and economics of ability taxation. It thus concludes that once we correctly understand its requirements we should reject the ability tax as unduly burdensome and unfair. This Article’s argument therefore constitutes a pressing challenge to the orthodoxy in public finance economics, as well as to the growing cadre of endowment tax partisans among political philosophers and scholars of tax law.


Scholarship, Tax, Tax Scholarship | Permalink