Paul L. Caron

Monday, December 3, 2018

Mason Presents The Illegality Of Digital Services Taxes Under EU Law Today At McGill

Mason (2016)Ruth Mason (Virginia) presents The Illegality of Digital Services Taxes Under EU Law: Size Matters (with Leopoldo Parada (Turin)) at McGill today as part of its Spiegel Sohmer Tax Policy Colloquium Series (more here):

This Article uses the example of company-size classifications to explore the role of disproportionate impact and legislative intent in judicial review of Member State laws for nationality discrimination. Our discussion of disproportionate impact is mostly descriptive—we explore how the Court has resolved questions of quantum and proof in the cases. Our discussion of intent is mostly normative—we argue, contrary to current doctrine, that courts should consider the legislature’s intentions as probative, but not dispositive, of discrimination.

We chose company size for two reasons. First, discussion of company size as covert nationality discrimination is new to the literature. Second, Member States increasingly use company-size classifications in tax laws; Poland and Hungary recently used turnover (as opposed to net income) to determine tax rates; and Spain proposes to use turnover to establish liability for its new digital services tax.

To illustrate how the Court of Justice might apply our approach to size discrimination, we consider whether the company-size thresholds in Spain’s and the EU’s recent proposals for a digital services tax constitute covert nationality discrimination. More generally, cooperative negotiations at the OECD towards reform that would appropriately tax the modern, digital economy must account for limitations imposed by EU law, and in particular its prohibition on nationality discrimination.

Colloquia, Scholarship, Tax | Permalink