Following up on my previous posts:
New York Law Journal, Jury Awards Former Columbia Business Prof $1.2M in Damages Over Retaliation for Sex Harassment Claims:
A former assistant professor at Columbia Business School was awarded $1.2 million by a Manhattan jury Friday, after finding the university and a top professor liable for retaliation over sexual harassment claims.
The jury awarded professor Enrichetta Ravina $750,000 in compensatory damages against Columbia and professor Geert Bekaert, as well as $500,000 in punitive damages against Bekaert. ...
[T]he jury found Bekaert and the school liable for retaliation against Ravina, who brought sexual harassment claims against Bekaert to the attention of school officials. She claimed Bekaert had made physical advances and discussed inappropriate sexual topics with her. When she refused to be romantic with him, Ravina claimed Bekaert thwarted her research and publication efforts. The school, she claimed, refused to help. Later, she was denied tenure.
Both Columbia and Bekaert denied the accusations, claiming that her failure to gain tenure was entirely based on her poor academic performance and inadequate work product.
During the three-week trial the jury was presented with email evidence showing Bekaert disparaging Ravina to colleagues throughout their mutual field of financial economics.
Poets & Quants, Prof Wins $1.25 Million From Columbia & B-School Professor Geert Bekaert:
A federal jury awarded former Columbia Business School Assistant Professor Enricheeta Ravina $1.25 million in damages in a highly publicized sexual harassment and retaliation trial that lasted more than two weeks in U.S. District Court in New York.
The award falls far short of the more than $30 million Ravina was seeking and follows a highly contentious dispute by lawyers in the case about what the untenured professor would be able to say in front of jurors hearing the damages portion of the case. Among other things, Ravina suggested that Columbia’s decision not to give her tenure would likely mean she will end up at a business school ranked 30th to 40th, a fate she contended would greatly diminish future opportunities in pay, retirement income, consulting, directorships on boards, and even a possible stake in an early stage company in exchange for advisory work.
The back-and-forth among the lawyers and judge that preceded the award provides a fascinating glimpse of life in academia at a top business school, including conversations about housing allowances for Columbia and NYU Stern professors, mortgage support for professors at Stanford University’s Graduate School of Business, and estimates that consulting work for Ravina would have been worth as much as $800 an hour, or $500,000 a year, along with directorships would have earned her roughly $8.6 million over her lifetime, if only she had been granted tenure at a top ten business school.
- Bloomberg, Columbia on the Hook for Professor Retaliation in Bias Case
- Bloomberg, Columbia Bias Case Ends in $1.3 Million Payout to Professor
- BuzzFeed News, This Columbia Professor Allegedly Told His Coworker He Was “Horny” And Tried To Kiss Her. A Jury Said It’s Not Sexual Harassment.
- Law 360, Columbia, Prof Liable For Retaliating Against Ex-Colleague
- New York Daily News, Columbia Business Professor Retaliated Against Female Colleague Who Claimed Harassment, Jury Finds
- New York Post, Ex-Columbia Researcher Awarded $1.25M in Pervy Colleague Retaliation Case
- New York Times, Former Assistant Professor Wins Retaliation Claim Against Columbia
- Wall Street Journal, Jury Says Columbia Professor Retaliated Against Colleague