Paul L. Caron

Sunday, November 30, 2014

The Research Productivity of New PhDs in Economics: The Surprisingly High Non-success of the Successful

John P. Conley (Vanderbilt) & Ali Sina ├ľnder (Bayreuth), The Research Productivity of New PhDs in Economics: The Surprisingly High Non-success of the Successful:

We study the research productivity of new graduates from North American PhD programs in economics from 1986 to 2000. We find that research productivity drops off very quickly with class rank at all departments, and that the rank of the graduate departments themselves provides a surprisingly poor prediction of future research success. For example, at the top ten departments as a group, the median graduate has fewer than 0.03 American Economic Review (AER)-equivalent publications at year six after graduation, an untenurable record almost anywhere. We also find that PhD graduates of equal percentile rank from certain lower-ranked departments have stronger publication records than their counterparts at higher-ranked departments. In our data, for example, Carnegie Mellon's graduates at the 85th percentile of year-six research productivity outperform 85th percentile graduates of the University of Chicago, the University of Pennsylvania, Stanford, and Berkeley. These results suggest that even the top departments are not doing a very good job of training the great majority of their students to be successful research economists. Hiring committees may find these results helpful when trying to balance class rank and place of graduate in evaluating job candidates, and current graduate students may wish to re-evaluate their academic strategies in light of these findings.

Table 2

Table 3

(Hat Tip: Inside Higher Ed.)

Legal Education, Scholarship, Tax | Permalink


Are these findings similar to some research on natural science students? I don't remember where, but I have read somewhere about some research showing that in natural science the rank IN class is more important than the rank OF the class, when it comes to predicting academic success.

Posted by: GSo | Dec 1, 2014 5:39:09 AM

For what really happens in the world of economics scholars, read Paul Krugman's recent "floating crap game" blog post.

Posted by: Bob Kamman | Dec 1, 2014 9:24:31 AM