Paul L. Caron

Friday, July 20, 2012

Horwitz: What Ails the Law Schools?

Paul Horwitz Horwitz(Alabama), What Ails the Law Schools?, 111 Mich. L. Rev. ___ (2013):

Everyone engaged in legal education and not utterly asleep agrees that there is a "law school crisis." Building on recent works by Brian Tamanaha [Failing Law Schools] and Walter Olson [Schools for Misrule: Legal Academia and an Overlawyered America], this paper discusses its causes and potential solutions, using a typical dichotomy in recent populist movements -- the "one percent" versus "99 percent" meme -- as a lens. It examines arguments that the problem is economic and that it is primarily cultural; although I conclude the problem is economic and structural far more than cultural, I also argue that one of Tamanaha's primary recommendations for reform -- that law schools ought to display more experimentation and institutional pluralism, and that ABA accreditation requirements ought to make this more possible -- goes some way toward addressing both diagnoses. The paper is more descriptive than prescriptive, although I offer some thoughts on solutions. I emphasize three things: 1) law schools would be better off focusing on regional than national markets, although the US News rankings make regionally oriented approaches more difficult; 2) a serious increase in meaningful faculty governance and involvement is needed; and 3) the role and needs of the client have been surprisingly marginal in recent discussions of law school reform. The client needs to be a prominent part of reform discussions, which suggests, contrary to some extant views, that curricular reform ought to continue to be part of the discussion along with economic and structural reform.

This is an early and imperfect draft intended for discussion and feedback, given both the importance of the issue and the need for increased public discussion. Comments are welcome.

Book Club, Legal Education | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Horwitz: What Ails the Law Schools?:


Anon is either a troll or simply deranged. His error in conflating "lawyers" with law school graduates has been pointed out to him several times. He never responds, he just continues to do it.

Posted by: Steven | Jul 22, 2012 12:11:35 PM


Where are all the books and articles from those who can do math, defending law schools and the present legal market?

Whether "lawyers are doing better than everyone else in a down economy" is irrelevant to the fact that legal education is in a crisis. Regardless, unemployed law grads aren't considered "lawyers" for the stats that purport to demonstrate that the legal profession is fairing better than others. Meanwhile, actual numbers clearly demonstrate that the legal profession is rapidly contracting.

Maybe you can be the first to author an article disputing that there is a law school crisis. Jack Marshall could co-author.

Posted by: Anon2 | Jul 21, 2012 12:56:03 PM

Dear god.

Yet another article about the business of law schools from a law professor teaching a soft non-business, non-quantitative subject.

There's a reason all of these books and articles about troubles in the legal market are written by people who can't do math.

Because if they understood how to look at the data, they would know that lawyers are doing better than everyone else in a down economy.

There is no crisis in the legal profession.

There is a recession affecting everyone, and lawyers are doing better than most.

Posted by: Anon | Jul 20, 2012 6:42:55 AM