Thursday, August 28, 2014
Omri Y. Marian (Florida), Home-Country Effects of Corporate Inversions, 90 Wash. L. Rev. ___ (2015):
This article develops a framework for the study of the unique effects of corporate inversions (meaning, a change in corporate-residence for tax purposes) in the jurisdictions from which corporations invert (“home jurisdictions”). Currently, empirical literature on corporate inversions overstates its policy implications. It is frequently argued that in response to an uncompetitive tax environment, corporations may relocate their headquarters for tax purposes, which, in turn, may result in the loss positive economic attributes in the home jurisdiction (such as capital expenditures, R&D activity, and high-quality jobs). The association of tax-residence relocation with the dislocation of meaningful economic attributes, however, is not empirically-supported and is theoretically-tenuous. The article uses case studies to fill this gap. Based on observed factors, the article develops grounded propositions that may describe the meaningful effects of inversions in home jurisdictions. Such propositions may guide future empirical research aimed at identifying the meaningful effects of inversions. The case studies suggest that whether tax-relocation is associated with the dislocation of meaningful economic attributes in home-jurisdictions is a highly contextualized question. It seems, however, that inversions are more likely to be associated with dislocation of meaningful attributes when non-tax factors support the decision to invert.