TaxProf Blog

Editor: Paul L. Caron, Dean
Pepperdine University School of Law

Friday, June 15, 2012

Harvey Golub: A Simple Tax Code Is a Fair Tax Code

Wall Street Journal op-ed:  A Simple Tax Code Is a Fair Tax Code, by Harvey Golub (former Chairman & CEO, American Express):

President Obama says over and over again that high-income Americans don't pay their fair share of income taxes. He says this with such conviction and confidence that many believe him—the tax code is unfair because high-income people pay too little. True, there is a lot wrong with our tax code and it is unfair, but the president is simply wrong if he believes our highest earners are not paying their fair share.

The top 1% of taxpayers pay more in federal income taxes than the bottom 90%. (The bottom 50% pay no income tax at all.) Clearly, our tax system is highly progressive, either when considering income taxes alone or consolidating personal income, corporate, estate and payroll taxes. ...

It's also true that our tax code is replete with preferences, penalties and subsidies of all kinds. On this issue, I agree with the president that it is unfair, although we disagree both on the nature of the unfairness and what to do about it. ...

What should be done to improve our arcane, complicated and unfair tax system? First, eliminate all preferences in the tax code and, if we still want to subsidize certain behaviors, pay for them through a legislative appropriations process, making them transparent to the public. In other words, everyone earning the same amount of money should pay the same in federal taxes, regardless of how they earned their money and regardless of how they choose to spend it. What would be fair is all Americans paying federal taxes on all their income, whether it is earned in the form of cash or benefits, and paying taxes on earnings only once.

Such a tax code would be very simple—count all income whether in cash or kind, whether in dividends or interest, whether in capital gains or salary. From that total income, subtract any amount saved for retirement or invested. Borrowing and withdrawals from retirement savings would be taxed as income in the year withdrawn. Taxes owed would then be computed on a flat rate for everyone, which I prefer, or a graduated rate to maintain a level of progressivity. Economists refer to this as a "personal expenditure tax" or "consumed-income tax."

To make sure taxes are paid only once and at a consistent rate no matter how individuals choose to spend their money, first eliminate deductions for state and local taxes and charitable and mortgage-interest payments and other preference items. Second, eliminate corporate taxes entirely and tax dividend income and capital gains at the same rate as salary or wages when received by individuals. And third, eliminate estate taxes since those earnings have already been taxed. Instead, receipts by heirs would be subject to tax when received by them.

Such a tax code would be fair, transparent and consistent. After an appropriate phase-in, all deductions would be eliminated in return for a lower rate across the board. Compliance and reporting costs would be far lower, and I believe revenues would be higher. It would eliminate the need for individuals and corporations to spend billions trying to influence the tax code or avoiding the payment of taxes, thus contributing to savings and capital investments, spurring economic growth and creating jobs.

Americans are very cynical about the tax code. They believe it rewards powerful, relatively narrow interests at their expense. And they are right. Americans also like their particular "loophole" or tax benefit. I believe they would be willing to give up their preferences if everyone does the same. That would be fair.

Tax | Permalink

TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Harvey Golub: A Simple Tax Code Is a Fair Tax Code:


Tax reform in 100 words. Golub is on the right track.

“Income” is everything of value we receive during the year, regardless of its source or character.

The only deduction is for legitimate charitable contributions.
The personal exemption is $32K per person. This offsets the loss of all our existing deductions, etc., and is the key element of this plan.

The estate tax is replaced by including wealth received as income to the heirs.

All “Income,” less the exemption, is taxed at the uniform (FLAT) rate of 32%.

This system remains progressive, and is radically simple. The exemption amount and tax rate can be adjusted and optimized based on CBO analysis.

Posted by: Robert R. Geary | Jun 21, 2012 10:06:45 AM