January 30, 2011
'Hard-Ass' Larry Summers v. 'Tiger Mom' Amy Chua on Developing Children (and Faculty)Weekend Wall Street Journal, Larry Summers vs. the Tiger Mom:
In one of the most entertaining of the sessions at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, this week, the organizers pitted Larry Summers, the former Treasury secretary, Harvard president and recently departed Obama administration chief economic adviser, against Prof. Chua. Harvard vs. Yale, West vs. East, Economist vs. Lawyer, Permissive Postmodern Parent vs. Dictatorial Disciplinarian of Daughters.
Prof. Summers, for a start, is evidently no pushover parent himself. At the meeting, organized by the Global Agenda Councils, he instantly acknowledged that he bears no resemblance to the indulgent, indolent Western stereotype Ms. Chua excoriates in her book "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother," first excerpted in The Wall Street Journal earlier this month. In fact, he noted ... that his own reputation—at home as much as in his professional life—was as something of a "hard-ass." ...
[Summers] recalled anyway some of his more turbulent exchanges [at Harvard], like the time he once told puzzled faculty members: "I think you have to decide whether achievement is the route to self-esteem or whether self-esteem is the route to achievement. I think you guys think self-esteem is the route to achievement, and I think you're wrong."
And yet even the stern intendant of traditional academic values couldn't quite bring himself to endorse the hard-ass Asian mothering style. Surprisingly for an academic who has won almost all the glittering prizes, he challenged the idea—cherished by Ms. Chua and her admirers—that academic success as a route to a rewarding career should be the sum of a child's ambitions.
"Which two freshmen at Harvard have arguably been most transformative of the world in the last 25 years?" he asked. "You can make a reasonable case for Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg, neither of whom graduated." If they had been the product of a Tiger Mom upbringing, he added, their mothers would probably have been none too pleased with their performance.
The A, B and C alums at Harvard in fact could be broadly characterized thus, he said: The A students became academics, B students spent their time trying to get their children into the university as legacies, and the C students—the ones who had made the money—sat on the fund-raising committee.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'Hard-Ass' Larry Summers v. 'Tiger Mom' Amy Chua on Developing Children (and Faculty):
One hopes hard-ass Larry is a better parent than he was an economic adviser.
When does he start his consulting gig with Goldman Sachs?
Posted by: save_the_rustbelt | Jan 30, 2011 9:47:12 AM
I'm just amazed that anyone takes Amy Chua seriously. Here is someone on supposedly the best law faculty in the country whose online CV lists not a single book, and barely any articles, with an academic publisher. Her husband writes novels and she writes parenting books. And people want to know why Yale is losing faculty?
Posted by: mike livingston | Jan 30, 2011 11:16:59 AM
Weren't Gates and Zuckerberg A students until they dropped out?
Aren't the C students on the fund-raising committe legacy students who inherited their wealth?
Isn't this an example of credentialed vs. educated? Larry Summers explained that once you have the credential of being accepted at Harvard, you don't actually have to learn anything.
Posted by: Joseph Hertzlinger | Jan 30, 2011 9:16:05 PM