Monday, February 15, 2010
The law as it presently exists requires the foregoing conclusion. We dislike it, for we are convinced it is an inequitable result. The next step would be for the Internal Revenue Service to tax the gold and silver in the medals awarded to Olympic Games' winners.
After the Wall Street Journal quoted me saying that the Wills case supports taxing Olympic athletes on the fair market value of their medals, I received this fan letter:
For the tax treatment of Olympic athletes in other countries, see Olympic Prize Money Should Be Tax Free:
With the issue of Olympic prize money in the news, let me get on one of my hobby horses. No, it's not that the men's hockey team shouldn't be getting the money. The Canadian Olympic Committee made the absolute right call in including them.
This has to do with the feeling in this corner that the money should be tax free for most of the athletes, not the men's hockey team, mind you.
It's tax free in such countries as China and Russia and probably many others, but not here.
The Aussies have really got it right. The Australian Olympic Committee waged a $1.1 million, 11-year court battle to make Olympic medal prize money tax-free for its athletes struggling to make ends meet. The only ones who pay taxes Down Under are those earning enough prize and sponsorship to be "carrying on a business of sport, " such as former swim star Ian Thorpe.
That two-tiered system makes perfect sense and let's hope someone in Canada with some clout takes up that fight for the athletes. ... It bothers me that sport, in this case Olympic sport, gets treated as a bastard child when it comes to considering the merits of athletic contributions to society.
Prize money in the arts and sciences – book awards and such – can be considered tax-exempt by the Canada Revenue Agency as a "prescribed prize," which are described in the regulations as those received for "meritorious achievement in the arts, the sciences or service to the public."
Well, winning an Olympic medal at a home Olympics is a “service to the public” these eyes when you consider the feelings of national pride that will be created.
When the COC introduced prize money for the first time for the 2008 Beijing Olympics, they requested and received an opinion from the CRA stating it was taxable income.
In Ontario, assuming an athlete had no additional income and was single, that meant a $2,140 hit on gold-medal prize money of $20,000 and $1,037 on the silver-medal award of $15,000. Bronze-medal winners wouldn't have to pay taxes on their $10,000 if they didn't make additional income.
Anyway, this is the perfect time for someone to take up this battle for Canada's Olympians. More than the money involved, it's the principle, that what they do should be seen as valuable to their country. Most certainly aren't getting paid much for it.
Update: For an Iowa meeting of tax blogger communists, see here.