« Daye on The Limits of Data in Law School Affirmative Action Debate | Main | Law Profs Remember 9/11 »
September 11, 2006
IRS Reaches Largest Tax Settlement in History: Glaxo to Pay $3.4 Billion
The IRS announced today (IR-2006-142) that it has resolved the largest tax dispute in American history: a transfer pricing dispute with Glaxo SmithKline Holdings (Americas) Inc. & Subsidiaries (“GSK”):
Under the settlement agreement, GSK will pay the IRS $3.4 billion, and will abandon its claim seeking a refund of $1.8 billion in overpaid income taxes, as part of an agreement to resolve the parties' long-running transfer pricing dispute for the tax years 1989 through 2005....
The Tax Court dispute for years 1989-2000 involves intercompany transactions between GSK and certain of its foreign affiliates relating to various GSK "heritage" pharmaceutical products. Specifically at issue is the level of U.S. profits reported by GSK after making intercompany payments that took into account product intangibles developed by and trademarks owned by its U.K. parent, and other activities outside the U.S., and the value of GSK's marketing and other contributions in the U.S. Under the settlement agreement, GSK has conceded over 60% of the total amount put in issue by the two parties for the years pending in Tax Court....
IRS Chief Counsel Donald Korb praised the extraordinary efforts of the Manhattan-based trial team handling the case in bringing about such an outstanding result for the Government. "I am often asked the question," Mr. Korb said, "whether the Chief Counsel lawyers are being constantly outgunned by the large law firms they face in the big dollar cases in the Tax Court. During my tenure as Chief Counsel it has become quite evident to me that our lawyers can go up against the best firms the private tax bar has to offer in the Tax Court and achieve quite successful results."
See the Glaxo press release. For press reports, see:
September 11, 2006 in New Cases | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c4eab53ef00d834e5881d69e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference IRS Reaches Largest Tax Settlement in History: Glaxo to Pay $3.4 Billion:
Comments
Man...
I'm sorry, but these people get off WAY too easy. They tried to steal BILLIONS from American taxpayers. $3.4b = Ten bucks from every single home in America basically.
They shouldn't be getting off with a fine. The entire board of directors should face public execution on TV. Cut off their heads, with their families in the audience forced to watch, and then see if anyone else wants to try this kind of theft in the future.
There are people sitting in your US prisons for life without possibility of parole on a third strike for stealing a candy bar, or for simple tresspassing. Well I'm sorry, but if those guys deserve life without possibility of parole, ALL these corporate thieves deserve to die.
Posted by: hsing lee | Sep 11, 2006 4:30:43 PM
"Over and over again courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging one's affairs as to keep taxes as law as possible. Everybody does so, rich or poor; and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands: taxes are enforced exactions, not voluntary contributions. To demand more in the name of morals is mere cant." Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Newman, 159 F.2d 848, 850--851 (CA2 1947) (Learned Hand, dissenting).
Posted by: andy | Sep 11, 2006 10:44:51 PM
hmmmmmmm, i think death might be a wee bit extreme, how about just publicly torturing them for a few weeks instead?
actually, if you consider the time value of money, it's probably not even 3.4billion. however, also take into account the millions of dollars in legal fees they incurred along the way, and the fact that some member(s) of their BoD might get bounced, along with some executive level management, and it starts to even out.
i'm quite impressed, transfer pricing is an incredibly complex issue all by its lonesome. throw in all those other 482 items, and i get visions of RA's and economists tearing their hair out. kudos to counsel for having the tenacity to stick with it.
Posted by: cpinva | Sep 11, 2006 11:43:03 PM
Smith Glaxo Kline is a disgusting corporation. They have been abusing the american public for far too long. They have outright lied about their products addictive tendency. Paxil is a disgusting example of how far these scumbags will go to medicate the american people. The lied about Paxil's withdrawal sympton causing untold physical and mental damage on thousands of American and European citizens. The entire board of directors should be arrested and charge with numereous felonies. Damn these people to hell.
Posted by: flyontheouterwall | Sep 12, 2006 3:04:06 AM
Glaxo settled just to save their headache and legal costs which are quite daunting in US. There is always a chance that the case may get over-turned in Supreme Court
Posted by: srinivasan | Sep 21, 2006 5:58:28 AM






